2018-10-11

SCMP Covers Real Estate Rage

SCMP: Public anger in China spreading as property prices drop
Not only were their sales figures grim for September, but the seven-day national holiday last week also brought at least two fangnao incidents – when homeowners protest against price cuts offered by developers to new buyers.

These protests are often directed at sales offices, with varying levels of intensity – from throwing rocks to holding banners and putting up funeral wreaths. As home ownership has remained the most important channel of investment for urban households in China in the past decade, price cuts have become increasingly unacceptable and a cause for social unrest.

In eastern Jiangxi province last week, angry homeowners who paid full price for units at the Xinzhou Mansion residential project in Shangrao attacked the Country Garden sales office after finding out it had offered discounts to new buyers of up to 30 per cent.

A similar incident took place in suburban Shanghai, where the same developer slashed prices at another project called One Mansion by a quarter.

“Property accounts for roughly 70 per cent of urban Chinese families’ total assets – a home is both wealth and status. People don’t want prices to increase too fast, but they don’t want them to fall too quickly either,” said Shao Yu, chief economist at Oriental Securities.
More rage is expected.
Zhang Dawei, chief analyst at Centaline Property, warned that not only were the overall sales dropping, but poor construction quality could also be a cause for more violence. “Try not to buy homes built in 2018, because while the developers were short of money, the same is the case with contractors,” he said.

“The fourth quarter would be a peak time for residential project completion. Issues which used to be papered over by rising prices could erupt in this period… so we should look out for a sudden surge of fangnao in the coming months,” he said.

NDRC Calls For Accelerated Fertility Suppression

China Banking News: NDRC Calls for 100 Million More Chinese to Be Settled in Cities
The directive says that the settlement of 100 million people in urban areas is a “key mission for advancing high-quality new-model urbanisation….an organic integration point for expanding domestic demand and improving the livelihood of the people [and] an intrinsic requirement for the comprehensive establishment of a well-off society that benefits a larger population.”

2018-10-10

Update: Vanke Says False Crying Children Get Milk: Vanke Refunding Homebuyers 1 Million Yuan Following Price Drop

Update: Vanke says the story is false.

Wallst.cn: 戏精万科
In 2014, Vanke threw out the "silver theory" and lowered the price again.

In 2018, Vanke will not only take the lead in price cuts, but also enable "price protection."

Vanke "first down to respect", the refund rumors are not true
The article sees trouble for the housing market, including for Vanke.
Can Vanke really survive?

In August, Vanke's sales amount and sales area both reached the lowest this year except February; the rate of removal in July was 51%, and the rate of removal in August was only 47%, significantly lower than the rate of 55% to 65% in the first half of the year. . Behind it, Vanke is facing greater regulatory pressures in more than 600 projects in first- and second-tier cities, and the diversification of long-term rental apartments, logistics real estate, commercial real estate, etc., is also facing a great test.

As the industry booms down, Vanke’s anxiety that “the big ship is difficult to turn around” is indeed intensifying.

...High-sounding Vanke, who can't live, can live his own life, so that other housing companies can't live.

The turning point is currently, is this really different?

Yu Liang said that most of us have not experienced the policy adjustments of 2008, and many people have not responded to the most basic market signals. In 2012, Vanke judged that the industry entered a turning point. It was just a prediction. I don't know when there will be a real turning point. Today, the turning point is really coming.

It’s not that its cold now, it’s that it was a bit too hot in the past.
The last line in potentially good news for the economy, but its not good news for highly leveraged developers and speculators. For them, the spread between credit costs and price appreciation is all that matters.

Finally, although this story was false, it's rapid spread in Chinese social media shows the current state of social mood and the real estate sector.

Original post below:

Vanke is refunding 1 million yuan to homebuyers who paid 4 to 5 million yuan for homes now priced at 3 million yuan. Critics, including the oft-quoted Zhang Dawei of Centaline, say this sets a bad precedent because they're under no obligation. It is akin to "crying children get milk." Additionally, back in September 2008 amid a far steeper price decline and a global economy whose wheels were already coming off, Vanke refused compensation.
Meanwhile, Vanke is turning down all requests, saying compensation is not an item in the contract. But it has also said it does understand why customers are disappointed.

Sina: 别墅买贵了能退100万?万科回应:正在了解情况
It is reported that the developer has negotiated with the old owner and will compensate for the difference in the purchase price through refunds.

Recently, the first price cuts of a townhouse (villa) developed by Vanke in Xiamen have caused widespread concern. The total price of villas with a total price of 4 to 5 million yuan has fallen to less than 3 million yuan. It is reported that the developer has negotiated with the old owner and will compensate for the difference in the purchase price through refunds.

In this regard, a public relations officer of Vanke said to Zhongxin Jingwei, they are also understanding the situation.

If you buy expensive, you can give it back?
Prices have plummeted in the area of the development in question.
With the deepening of the regulation of the property market and the changes in the market environment, the Xiamen property market, which has been burning like oil, has gradually cooled down. Many real estate projects have made great efforts to reduce prices. Located in Xiang'an District of Xiamen, the first-ever Vanke Egret County has not had much advantage. In September, it also introduced a large preferential measure. The price was reduced from 4.5 million to 5 million yuan per townhouse to about 2.78 million yuan, the price in the area is about 2.98 million yuan per townhouse.

Zhongxin Jingwei learned that the previously sold villas were given 5,000 yuan/square meter for fine decoration and two underground parking spaces with a unit price of 160,000 yuan, while the special room was delivered with blanks, no parking spaces and indoor elevators. Even if the previously purchased villas plan to go to the decoration and parking space, the minimum total price is about 3.7 million yuan / set, and the price of the new special room is still cheaper by nearly 1 million yuan.

Many real estate agents said that after the price cut, the enthusiasm of buyers was high, and the special room was sold out on the opening day.
The old homebuyers are not happy:
The drop of nearly 1 million yuan in price has naturally caused dissatisfaction among the old owners. There is a WeChat public article saying that Egret County is preparing to refund the owner of the pre-purchased owner and is negotiating with the bank to change the mortgage contract. The owner who buys the expensive only needs to sign a supplementary agreement with the developer to ban the fine decoration and the free parking space agreed upon before, and the corresponding price reduction is about 1 million yuan, directly offsetting the mortgage part.

Zhongxin Jingwei asked several real estate agents. A Li surnamed intermediary in Chain Real Estate said that he had not heard of this news yet. He and his colleagues who had previously dealt with the customer did not give feedback to them. The intermediaries who found the new housing department of the two shells also said that they also saw the news on the Internet on the morning of the 10th and had not been notified from the real estate.

A consultant from Vanke Egret County said that it was indeed negotiating with the old owners, but the specific plan has not yet been fixed, and he does not understand the details.

At noon on the 10th, a public relations officer of Vanke responded to Zhongxin Jingwei: "We are also understanding the situation, and if there is a specific explanation, it will be released as soon as possible."
Has Vanke set a new standard for the industry? The positives are good PR (no smashed up sales offices) and possibly lower costs IF buyers have the right to return the home. Then developers would have to refund their money and sell it at the lower price. In those cases, compensating buyers may be the cheaper option.The downside is that many homebuyers do not have the right to return their home. For those homeowners, there's an incentive to smash up sales offices if it means receiving extra-contractual compensation.
Will other housing companies follow up?

Since September, the property market has suddenly turned cold. Some housing companies have begun to reduce sales prices through various preferential promotions. The price reduction of many real estates is relatively large. These measures have caused some old owners to feel that their own interests have been damaged. Before and after the National Day holiday, there have been many activists' actions to protect their rights.

Recently, it was reported that a sales office in Shangrao Country Garden in Jiangxi was smashed because the developer reduced the price from 10,000 yuan/square meter to 7,000 yuan/square meter, causing the old owners to defend their rights. At the same time, Country Garden was also exposed to lower prices in other places. Country Garden eventually had to clarify, saying that only a few cities have discounted individual projects.

Zhang Dawei, chief analyst of Zhongyuan Real Estate, believes that in the current weak market situation, some cities' real estate projects will not carry out price reduction promotion, sales performance will certainly not improve, but if the price is cut, once the owner checks out, things will become more complicated.

In fact, apart from Vanke, some housing companies have responded to this thorny problem in a similar way. In the face of the price reduction rights of the owners of Hangzhou Binjiang New Hope New City Future Coast Phase I, Binjiang Group agreed to check out and not charge any liquidated damages. In September, Hefei Taihe Yard reduced the price of some units from about 20,000 yuan / square meter to about 15,000 yuan / square meter, causing dissatisfaction with the early owners. Later, Taihe said to the media that the old owners can check out and then press the current offer. Price purchase.

For the price reduction of house prices, Zhang Dawei believes that although the developer can understand the behavior of accepting the negotiation from the perspective of maintaining the brand image, it may play a bad demonstration role for the market.

"The phenomenon of price reduction and rights protection is obviously not in line with the spirit of the contract. The troublemakers generally have the mentality of 'the crying children get milk', and from the historical point of view, most of the housing troublemakers get benefits, but those who don't cause trouble take losses."

MLF Outstanding September 2018

2018-10-09

Market Top Chart

Chinese Millennial Travelers Put Golden Week Trips on Credit

EO: 十一黄金周旅游消费掀热潮 调查显示近半数人 “借钱”也要出去玩
"borrowing money" also has to go out to play

Compared with the past, early consumption is becoming more and more popular in travel.

If the money is not enough, will you still choose to travel during the holidays? In the 360 ​​survey, more than half (54.55%) of the respondents chose “no, wait until they have enough money to go”. However, as many as 42.43% of the population said, “It will be convenient to use various travel stages or to swipe credit cards and flowers.” In addition, 3.02% of the population chose to borrow money from friends.

In the interview, the reporter found that although some 90's generation wages were not high, their consumption was higher than those of the 70's and 80's generations. "In fact, it is just to buy and buy, and spent a total of several tens of thousands of dollars. They all brushed credit cards, or used flowers and other methods, and then slowly returned." Xiao Wang, born in 1995, told reporters. Xiao Wang belongs to the "moonlight family" and believes that young people should go out and take time to play, buy and buy.

Some 80s later believe that today's various types of consumer loans and installment products are very convenient to use. Even if they are not bad, they will choose this type of payment when they go out. "Deposits keep money, and most of them use credit cards when they spend." Ms. bluntly, but even if she lacks money, she will definitely not borrow money from her friends.

China Endgame, Again

Ludwig Von Mises explains China's endgame.
True, governments can reduce the rate of interest in the short run. They can issue additional paper money. They can open the way to credit expansion by the banks. They can thus create an artificial boom and the appearance of prosperity. But such a boom is bound to collapse soon or late and to bring about a depression.
The essence of a credit-expansion boom is not overinvestment, but investment in wrong lines, i.e., malinvestment.
What is needed for a sound expansion of production is additional capital goods, not money or fiduciary media. The credit boom is built on the sands of banknotes and deposits. It must collapse.
If the credit expansion is not stopped in time, the boom turns into the crack-up boom; the flight into real values begins, and the whole monetary system founders.
There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as the result of voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as a final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved.

Global Times: Beijing needs proactive stimulus policies to shield economy from worst of trade war
China is in a critical period of stabilizing its economy. One decade after the global financial crisis, the Chinese economy is again facing uncertainty and challenges under internal and external pressure. It may be that China can't overcome these difficulties by simply continuing to fine-tune its economic policy. To maintain a stable trend in economic development, strong measures must be taken to support growth.

China will adopt more proactive fiscal measures, such as tax cuts, to help businesses affected by the trade conflict with the US, Chinese Finance Minister Liu Kun has said.

Total tax cuts for 2018 are expected to exceed 1.3 trillion yuan ($189 billion). The country will also study more large-scale tax reductions, Liu said in an interview with the Xinhua News Agency.

...Apart from steps China has already announced to reduce business costs, the country needs to draw up more policies to reduce taxes and support the real economy. Liu's comments about large-scale tax cuts are timely and necessary to ease investors' concerns. The questions are: How soon can those measures be taken and how proactive will the policies be?

In 2008, the Chinese government announced a 4 trillion yuan stimulus package to fight the impact of the global financial crisis. Now, the Chinese economy is under even tougher pressure amid escalating trade friction. Beijing must draw up strong stimulus policies to inject new momentum into the real economy.
I'm no advocate of big deficit spending, but of all the types of deficit spending that exist, structural changes to the tax system are among the least destructive for the economy. China needs efficient capital allocation, not a new round of infrastructure investment. China avoided an endgame in 2008, in 2011 and in 2014, each time finding there was plenty more room for centrally-directed credit investment. Can they do it again?
Global Times: China GDP to grow 6.2% in 2019: IMF
Maurice Obstfeld, Economic Counsellor and Director of the IMF Research Department, stressed during an IMF press conference on Tuesday that the trade dispute China is currently having with the US will negatively impact the country's GDP growth next year, although such a negative influence will be offset by Chinese authorities' efforts to stabilize the economy.

The IMF forecasted that China's GDP growth will be 6.6 percent this year, the same forecast in April.

Liu Xuezhi, an economist at Bank of Communications, told the Global Times on Tuesday that the trade war will have an "evident" impact on the domestic economy.

"It is likely to drag back the mainland GDP by 0.1 to 0.2 percentage point for this year and next year. And if the trade disputes worsen, the drag will widen to 0.4 percent to 0.5 percent," Liu said.

...But experts said the Chinese government has the capacity to minimize such impact with the launch of more stimulus policies, especially policies to boost domestic consumption.

The People's Bank of China announced on Sunday to cut the reserve requirement ratio (RRR) by one percentage point from October 15.

"It's possible that the PBC will launch more RRR cuts before the end of this year," Liu said.
Some economists forecast a hit to consumption in 2019 because of social security reform.

Social Security Change Could Cause Layoffs and Shave 1.5pc Off GDP in 2019
Chinese SMEs Can Only Survive Through Tax Evasion, Social Security Reform Could Be Killer

Lower taxes are needed to offset tight financing conditions and a coming hit from back taxes, since many SMEs and their employees have dodged social insurance taxes for years.

FT: Will China’s stimulus prove a boon for emerging markets?
Jean-Charles Sambor, deputy head of EM debt at BNP Paribas Asset Management, said a move by China to deliver more stimulus would be “positive news for the emerging market macro story”.

“It means there’s a low risk of a hard landing . . . so imports should remain quite strong, commodity prices quite strong, and therefore any pass-through would have a positive impact on . . . commodity exporters.”

China, for example, is the biggest destination for Brazilian exports, and there are already signs that other EMs are benefiting as the country grapples with economic growth that slowed in the second quarter to a pace last seen in 2016.

Li-Gang Liu, chief China economist at Citi, said China previously bought a lot of oil and gas from the US, but said that was “cut to zero” in August. Meanwhile, in the area of agriculture, “if you look at the price differential between soyabean prices in the US and Brazil, Brazil is now 25 per cent more expensive”, he added.
Missing from most discussions about China is its inefficient capital allocation. During a rising credit cycle, everything looks good because debts are financed. Only when the tide reverses will you see the true extent of malinvestment.

The dollar is a problem for China, but even if it abandons the dollar, the yuan will devalue against real assets. Major economic reform is the only way out, but major economic reform entails giving up political control over the economy. The behavior of the CCP indicates it prefers political control to economic reform.

2018-10-08

Chinese Developers Resume 10pc Down, Free BMW, Free Rooms, Coupons

Chinese developers offered free rooms, purchase with only 10 percent down, free cars with a purchase and even coupons for cash rebates to entice buyers over the Golden Week. They also enticed non-qualified buyers by offering sales that will become official when they qualify.

Caijing: 黄金周楼市凉:北京深圳成交量腰斩 一成首付再现
In Beijing, at least six properties have undergone price cuts or increased incentives. For example, a real estate in Fangshan District will be offered in the form of a special room, and the average price will drop from 38,900 yuan per square meter to 35,000 yuan.

In Shanghai, there are not only price cuts, but also delivery. For example, two properties in Songjiang and Jiading will be priced at 8.9 percent on the basis of the original price. If the company recommends the purchase of a house, it can also add a discount of 9.8 percent, and then send a 30,000 yuan purchase coupon. Another example is a real estate in Baoshan, which has launched a special offer of “buy a house to send a BMW”. If you don’t need a car, you can get a discount of about 300,000 yuan.

The promotion of the second-tier city property market is even stronger. For example, in Hefei, the price of Daping will be reduced from the previous hardcover of 22,000 yuan per square meter to the average price of blanks of 17,400 yuan, 10 percent down to buy, and non-resident buyers can wait for social insurance. In addition, in Dongguan, Chongqing and other third- and fourth-tier cities, developers are also reducing prices.

2018-10-07

Hangzhou Developers Cancelling Housing Lotteries for Lack of Interest

One of the bellwether markets for housing sentiment in recent years, Hangzhou is showing signs of rapid cooling. Developers have begun supplementing housing lotteries with direct sales and some have even cancelled their lotteries.

iFeng: 多地因楼盘降价引发纠纷 楼市几大信号不可不重视
Two major signals cannot be ignored

Zhang Dawei, chief analyst of Zhongyuan Real Estate, said that due to the increase in the supply of new homes, the inventory of typical cities including Beijing, Nanjing, Shenzhen, Ningbo and Fuzhou has increased to varying degrees. At the same time, hot cities are still under strict control, credit tightening, not only commercial loans continue to be high pressure, the provident fund policy has also begun to tighten in many cities across the country, making the market continue to wait and see. At this stage, the purchasing power of buyers is hard to support the market to continue to rise. Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Nanjing, Hefei and other cities have seen signs of falling prices.

In addition, several major signals in the property market also convey important information -

1 sales department disputes are more and more

At present, the price reduction in the property market is not yet widespread, and it only appears in case projects in a small number of cities. Guo Yi, deputy general manager and chief analyst of Siyuan Real Estate Market Development Department, said that although “households are not speculative”, even if they are self-occupied buyers, they hope that the value of assets will continue to rise and they will be held in historical verification. Optimistic expectations, it is difficult to accept the price reduction behavior of housing companies, especially in a short period of time, the price of real estate has been lowered. The emergence of disputes is also one of the manifestations of the real price cuts of housing companies and the cold turnover of the property market.

2 lottery winning rate is getting higher and higher

The housing lottery is itself a response to a hot property market. It is an important signal when the lottery win rate is getting higher and higher, and even lotteries that don't sell out.

Taking Hangzhou as an example, the reporter learned that since September, there have been more and more limited-price real estate listings. Buyers tend to be rational, and the wait-and-see attitude is obvious. The lottery rate is getting higher and higher, and many real estates have supplemented the lottery and opened for sale. There are even some phenomena in some properties, such as the phenomenon of canceling the lottery. Some insiders pointed out that perhaps the future non-popular real estate will not need the housing lottery.

RRR Cut Offers No Hope for Housing Market

iFeng: 释放7500亿元流动性 央行降准给予房地产什么信号
Regarding the impact of the RRR on the property market, Zhang Hongwei, director of the same property research department, believes that because of the heavy firewalls for the financing channels of housing enterprises, most of them cannot enter the development field. This money has nothing to do with real estate. Very nervous, the general trend of price cuts in the property market will not change.

Another background for the central bank to be able to lower the RRR is that the real estate market has been basically controlled. At present, due to the decline in the scale of shantytown renovation, the real estate market in the third and fourth tier cities has begun to fall. Affected by the strict regulation of real estate and the control of bank credit, the real estate market in some second-tier cities accelerated, while the real estate in the first-tier cities kept the price falling and the volume contracted.

In addition, discussions about property taxes are also affecting the expectations of market-related entities. As long as the real estate market is not loosely regulated, the central bank's RRR cut is expected to have a very limited impact on the real estate market. Real estate companies should still be prepared for the winter.

In the first half of the year, due to the tight funding of major banks, almost all the real estate market faced more serious financing problems. Therefore, everyone is suffering. In the second half of the year, with the continuous implementation of the four RRR cuts, the flow of banks Sex began to get a certain improvement. At this time, the Matthew effect of the real estate market will be further exerted. Large-scale and leading real estate enterprises are more likely to obtain more funds from the banks because of their better credit records in the banks.

Chinese Homebuyers Wait and See During National Holiday

During Golden Week, some real estate agents went on vacation themselves given the calm in the normally roaring housing market. Anecdotal evidence from Sanya, Suzhou and other cities points to a swift cooldown as buyers wait for lower prices. Sentiment has shifted.

People's Daily: 观望多成交少 国庆长假楼市“哑火”
The "Golden September and Silver 10" National Day holiday is often a hot period of stepping on the plate and buying a house, but this year's Golden Week, the property market is a bit "dumb". Although the major real estate developers have thrown preferential olive branches, the sales office still feels "cool". According to industry insiders, the overall property market of the National Day holiday was stable, and the market gradually showed a high level of decline.

  Yan Yan is a salesman of a real estate in a second-tier city. This National Day is not busy. She took a group of customers to see the room and also took a break with her colleagues for two days. In the first few months, she will receive dozens of customers in one day.

  "In recent years, there have been few calm periods during holidays." Yan Yan said that this year's National Day, their company in some other cities and cities also appeared a bit deserted.

  Sanya, which has always been a popular city for real estate, is no exception. During the National Day, the real estate exhibition hall on the first floor of the Sanya Real Estate Service Center only had a brief introduction of real estate projects and some chairs, and chose a closed door.

  Not far from it, the “Wanke Lakeside Holiday Park” project recently launched the first shot of the price reduction of Sanya housing enterprises. "The filing price is about 29,000 yuan. After all kinds of discounts, the minimum price can reach 26,000 yuan." According to the salesperson, the current sales situation is definitely not comparable to the beginning of the year. "There are too few people who are eligible to buy a house. We have no choice but to cut prices."

  Zhang Dawei, chief analyst of Zhongyuan Real Estate, said that on the one hand, most of the hotspot cities have a comprehensive price limit, and the real estate market has no dim peak season; on the other hand, it is related to the current high housing prices and the strong wait-and-see attitude of buyers.

  Zhang Dawei said that although many developers have prepared ammunition during the National Day, from the point of view of transactions, the city's property market has gradually begun to appear to fall back, and house price adjustment has begun to appear from point to region. Hot cities began to decline gradually, and purchasing power is hard to support the market to continue to rise.

  Taking Suzhou as an example, although there were 7 new properties opened on September 30, and more than 10 properties were held in the Golden Week, there was no phenomenon that buyers used the holidays to watch large-scale houses. According to statistics, at present, there are 43,613 sets of new homes sold in Suzhou, and only 290 sets will be sold on October 1 and only 105 sets on October 2. The second-hand housing market seems to be more deserted. In the first two days of the Golden Week, the volume of existing housing in the city was zero.

  In Jiangmen, multi-projects launched “special room”. Among them, Midea · Agile Park Tianyi launched four sets of "special room", the average price of about 10,000 yuan / square meter; Swan Bay launched 10 sets of the lowest unit price of 9500 yuan / square meter "special room"; Country Garden · Zhonghai Yu Yuefu Launched 10 sets of "special room", the average price was 12,600 yuan / square meter; Country Garden Xijiang Huafu 147 square meters unit hit 5 percent discount.

  The Xiangjiang Emerald Oasis in the Guangzhou metropolitan area is playing an advertisement for “full-size single contract, as long as 10% down payment, and National Day limited time six major gift packs!”.

  Some insiders said that during the National Day holiday this year, the property market showed a large promotion, but wait and see more transactions. Even the actual price of the first product is significantly lower than the previous “blowing price”, but it is still affected by the consumption power of regional customers.

  Zhang Dawei said that the property market has been heavily regulated, commercial loans have continued to tighten, and the provident fund policy has begun to tighten in many cities across the country, making the market continue to wait and see.

Guangzhou Homesellers Concede on Price

iFeng: 二手楼市现买方市场特征 业主大多价格让步
The characteristics of the “buyer market” of the existing property market in Guangzhou have become more and more prominent. Many agents said that in September, the sentiment of existing homeowners in the region was not as strong as before, and most of them will accept the price concessions.

China Cuts RRR 1pc, USDCNY Breakout to Follow Despite Govt Assurances


The relationship between RRR and CNY is fairly straightforward because the Chinese monetary system remains heavily reliant on U.S. dollar liquidity. When U.S. supply is expanding, the PBoC increases the RRR to soak up liquidity. When U.S. liquidity is tight, the PBoC cuts the RRR. This latest cut should unleash a rally in USDCNY towards 7 and then a breakout to the upside.
Nikkei: China slashes banks' reserve requirements as trade war imperils growth
China's central bank on Sunday announced a steep cut in the level of cash that banks must hold as reserves, stepping up moves to lower financing costs and spur growth amid concerns over the economic drag from an escalating trade dispute with the United States.

The reserve requirement cut, the fourth by the People's Bank of China (PBOC) this year, comes as Beijing has pledged to expedite plans to invest billions of dollars in infrastructure projects as the economy shows signs of cooling further, with investment growth slowing to a record low.

Reserve requirement ratios (RRRs) -- currently 15.5 percent for large commercial lenders and 13.5 percent for smaller banks -- would be cut by 100 basis points effective Oct. 15, the PBOC said, matching a similar-sized move in April.

Economists predicted further cuts ahead.
There were no trade wars in 2008, 2011 and 2015. There was dollar pressure. It has returned in 2018. Trade war is another straw on the camel's back, but the dollar is the far greater concern. Even without trade war, China would be cutting its RRR.

Official Response

The People's Bank of China and SAFE both issued statements defending the currency today, but they doth protest too much. While the move is not intended to weaken the yuan, it will weaken the yuan. China is in an unenviable position, albeit one of their own making thanks to years of dragging their heels, because actions they take to prop up the economy will increase depreciation pressure on the yuan.

People's Daily: 央行:降准释放约7500亿增量资金 不会对人民币形成贬值压力
Whether the RRR cut will increase the pressure on the RMB depreciation, the above-mentioned person in charge said that this RRR has made up for the liquidity gap of the banking system, optimized the liquidity structure, and the monetary policy has not relaxed. The market interest rate is stable, the broad money (M2) and The growth rate of social financing scale is basically matched with the nominal GDP growth rate, which is reasonable and moderate, and will not form depreciation pressure. This RRR cut is conducive to promoting economic restructuring and promoting high-quality development. The economy is basically facing the consolidation of the RMB exchange rate. As a large-scale developing economy, China's exports have strong competitiveness. At the same time, China's economy is dominated by domestic demand, manufacturing industries are complete, industrial systems are relatively complete, import dependence is moderate, and the RMB exchange rate has sufficient conditions to maintain a reasonable balance. Basically stable at the level. The People's Bank of China will continue to take necessary measures to stabilize market expectations and keep the foreign exchange market running smoothly.
People's Daily: 外汇局:外汇储备规模有望在波动中保持稳定
Wang Chunying, spokesperson of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, said that in September, China's foreign exchange market continued to maintain a stable overall trend, and the market participants' foreign-related transactions were more rational and orderly. In the international financial market, the US dollar index was basically the same as that at the end of August. The main non-US dollar currency exchange rate has risen and fallen, and the price of major national bonds has fallen slightly. The combination of exchange rate conversion and asset price changes has led to a slight decline in the size of foreign exchange reserves.

  Wang Chunying said that since the beginning of this year, in the face of the complicated external environment, China has adhered to the general tone of steady progress, deepened the reform and opening up, maintained a generally stable and stable economic situation, continued to optimize the economic structure, and flexible the two-way fluctuation of the RMB exchange rate. The company continued to strengthen, the balance of payments was basically balanced, and the scale of foreign exchange reserves remained generally stable.

  Looking forward to the future, Wang Chunying said that although the external environment still faces great uncertainty, China's economy has strong adaptability and ability to withstand external risks. The sound fundamentals will continue to provide a solid foundation for the smooth operation of the foreign exchange market. The comprehensive role of domestic and foreign factors, China's foreign exchange reserves are expected to remain stable in the volatility.
China announced its change in forex reserves today as well.

Xinhua: China's forex reserves edge down in September
China's foreign exchange reserves edged down 0.7 percent, or 22.7 billion U.S. dollars from a month earlier, to 3.087 trillion U.S. dollars by the end of September, the central bank said Sunday.

Wang Chunying, spokesperson of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, attributed the contraction to a number of factors including exchange rate conversion and changing asset prices.

"Bonds usually take up a large portion of many countries' forex reserves," said Zhao Qingming, chief economist of derivatives institute of China Financial Futures Exchange. "The interest rate hike by the Federal Reserve has led to declines in bond prices across the world, which also influenced the assest reassessment of China's forex reserves."

In addition, Japanese yen weakened over 2 percent, resulting in write-downs in the yen assets China held with its forex reserves.

According to Zhao's estimates, China's forex reserves lost about 10 billion U.S. dollars in book value because of the weakening of yen.
This is the price of dedollarization. China has diversified its assets and many of those assets are depreciating. USDJPY has broken out to the upside and EURUSD is threatening to breakdown.
Chinese reserves depreciated $22.7 billion, but only SDR 6.5 billion. The SAFE spokesman is correct in blaming forex movements, but this is only good news if you are neutral to bearish on the U.S. dollar. If the U.S. dollar breaks out, Chinese reserves will depreciate. The risk of capital controls failing, a speculative attack or depreciation expectations running wild on the Mainland become increasingly dangerous risks as reserves dwindle.
Even without a crisis in China, a move through USDCNY 7.0 will intensify pressure on Chinese trade partners. The real pain for emerging markets has yet to begin.

2018-10-06

Real Estate Rage Spreading As Developers Grab Golden Week Opportunity, Will 2019 Be the Year of Defending Rights?

Chinese developers are recouping capital amid tight credit conditions and they're doing it by slashing prices on new homes. Following the Mid-Autumn Festival, there were several reports of real estate rage around the country (See Fresh Reports of Real Estate Rage Signal Turn in Chinese Housing Market).The week ending Sunday, October 7 is Golden Week in China, the week-long holiday attached to the October 1 National Day. These holidays fall in what the real estate industry calls "Gold September and Silver October," when developers typically see strong sales. This year sales were weak in many parts of the country, forcing steeper price cuts than usual. Steep cuts that have been associated with prior turns in the real estate market.

Since price cutting triggers real estate rage, developers try to make stealth cuts. They adjust the property, upgrading the furnishings or giving away a parking spot for free to keep a price level, or downgrading the furnishings to cover the price cut. Slashing prices outright is a last resort because it induces anger from homeowners who see the value of their home cut by as much as one-third overnight.

Defending Rights

Real estate rage is dubbed defending rights (维权) in China. In some cases, homeowners may have legitimate grievances. Developers will promise to build amenities such as a kindergarten as part of a development. Sometimes these amenities come years later, if at all. Housing quality may be substandard. If developers haven't fulfilled their side of a contract, homeowners have a powerful case and the local government will get involved. In other cases, homeowners have less ground to stand on. They will demand a rebate equivalent to the price cut or they may demand their money back and return the property (退房).

Country Garden is the latest developer facing enraged homeowners "defending their rights." Here's a video from October 4 from Shangrao, Jiangxi province. Homeowners are protesting a 30 percent price cut, from 10,000 yuan per square meter to 7,000 yuan. The smash the sales office.
A protestor holds up a sign. The description below the picture says a first-phase owner still doesn't have his home and he paid 43 percent more that people buying the same property today.
Country Garden also outraged Shanghai homeowners in the Pudong area when it slashed prices from 35,000 yuan per sqm to 26,000 yuan. This protesters holds a sign that essentially translates as "Country Garden stole my hard earned money!"
I could not find an article covering this next case, but this post claims a similar protest in Jingdezhen, Jiangxi at an unnamed developer.
Here's another protest over one-third price cuts:
A news clip covering another incident at a real estate sales office. (Link: 百位业主维权回家,途经商业开幕现场被拦,现场一片混乱
Here is a related example that shows the overall social mood and attitude towards developers. A security guard employed by the developer blocked a car from entering the property late at night. The homeowner got into an argument with the guard. Several dozen homeowners came out to witness the argument and "defend their rights," prompting a response from the developer.

The flurry of protests and other anecdotal data, such as real estate agents changing professions, coincides with weaker sales data. It has analysts and media alike asking if the big turn in Chinese real estate has arrived.

Hanfeng: 黄金周楼市提前降温 房地产市场要变天?
In fact, the industry has long expected the “Golden September and Silver 10” to cool down significantly this year, besides the first- and second-tier cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Nanjing, Hangzhou and Xiamen, which are in a downturn. At present, even the third- and fourth-tier cities around Beijing, such as Langfang, Xianghe, Yanjiao, etc., have seen a sharp decline in house prices, and the transaction continues to shrink.

In addition to the cooling of new homes by the price limit policy, the second-hand housing market, which reflects the real situation of the market, is also showing a deteriorating trend. According to the data of the Shell Research Institute, the monthly listing price of 100 cities fell by the number of cities. From March to May this year, it was 19 per month, 25 in June, 19 in July, and suddenly increased to 47 in August.
Real estate agencies are closing, agents are changing professions:
Signs of cooling: The real estate agency is closed, and the employees switch

During the National Day holiday this year, there are very few real estate agents working in first- and second-tier cities, usually for five days. A real estate agent surnamed Yang in Beijing once said that she sold a suite in the first half of this year. She is now focusing on her own store, and she has stopped talking about housing prices.

As early as October 2016, Xiao Yang had traveled between Bazhou, Gu'an, Yongqing and Xianghe in Beijing. Throughout 2016, Xiao Yang sold 70 houses and earned nearly 3 million in one breath. At that time, it was too easy to make money in the real estate agency. I did not expect that the Beijing-based property market was affected by the regulation and control. Since 2017, the business has plummeted and there has been no volume.

In this regard, we feel that the real estate agency reshuffle is in front of us. On the one hand, due to the recent rectification of the mediation of housing prices and rents in various cities, a number of realtors have closed their offices. On the other hand, real estate began to cool down, real estate agency business is difficult to do, and a large number of people choose to change professions. This happened as early as 2008, but now it has been staged again.
Real estate rage is another sign:
Cooling sign 2: house price reduction promotion, owner's angry rights protection

Recently, news of developers' price cuts and owners' rights protection has been continuously transmitted. Just in the past Mid-Autumn Festival holiday, a developer in Hefei chose to reduce the price of some buildings by 4,000 yuan/square meter, which immediately led the old owners to block the door of the community and pull out the banner rights. The second phase of Hangzhou Binjiang Future Coast lowered the price by 400,000. As a result, the owners of the first phase ran to the sales office and denounced the developers for “arbitrarily pricing and deceiving the owners”.

What is even more funny is that just half a year ago, Hangzhou residents complained that it was not the house price reduction, but the purchase of the house. At that time, there were thousands of people involved in the lottery in almost all the popular properties, and even 70,000 people rushed to grab the 1500 listings. Many people have been very happy with the purchase of the house, they always believe that "buy a new house, is to make money."

In this regard, we believe that more and more owners have begun to defend their rights. This also invisibly tells those speculative needs. The days of buying a house and making quick money with a closed eye are gone forever. Now the investment in the real estate market is beginning to be risky. And the cold wave in the property market has come so fast that it is impossible for all parties to foresee.
For those who haven't seen it, check out Speculators Take Over Chinese Housing Market. Data collected by CHFS showed speculators grew to 50 percent of the homebuyer market in Q1 2018. Those speculators are the most likely to return the home or even resort to jingle mail if they end up with negative equity.
Cities are seeing failed land auctions as developers turn cautious:
Third sign of cooling: Failed land auctions, housing companies cautiously take the land

According to statistics from the Central Plains Real Estate Research Center, in 2018, the land premium rate of hot cities is basically around 10%, which is significantly lower than the average premium rate of 30% in 2015-2017. From January to July 2018, the number of land auctions in the country was close to 800, and the number of land auctions in second- and third- and fourth-tier cities increased by 200% and 121% year-on-year.

Since the beginning of this year, the land premium rate has continued to decline, and the number of land flow targets has increased sharply, in stark contrast to the booming land market in the previous two years. This is mainly because the desire of real estate developers to develop land is fading. Housing companies have taken the land from the past without cost, and now they are becoming more cautious and no longer dare to take the land at high prices. The real estate market is sluggish and the land market is cooling down.
Many developers are concerned about their survival:
Cooling sign four: Developers think about how to "live"

Judging from the situation in the first half of the year, the performance of leading housing companies this year is likely to hit the best performance in history. However, housing companies are worried about the crisis of survival. In late September, the real estate industry giant Vanke held an autumn meeting in Shenzhen. The three red-and-white letters hanged at the venue were very eye-catching: Survival.

Previously, influenced by real estate regulation, since last year, in addition to Vanke and Poly, more than 18 real estate companies such as Evergrande Real Estate, Franshion Real Estate, Sino-Ocean Land, Landsea Green Real Estate, Times Real Estate, AVIC Real Estate and Longhu Real Estate have dropped the word "real estate" from their names. This means that the company is positioned to upgrade, and the housing enterprises will develop towards a diversified path in the future.

It is worth mentioning that more and more real estates entered the price cuts in the third quarter, and the discounts of developers were much higher than the previous two years. In September, the brand housing enterprise Evergrande first made a nationwide promotion discount, with a 8.9 percent discount for residential and a 60 percent discount for shops; Taihe’s project offered a larger discount, and if the purchaser purchased the entire house, the house price would be 30% discount; The city opened the "100 billion offensive" special purchase season, according to the different regions, develop different price reduction strategies.
Developer Evergrande recently invested in a car dealership as it diversifies away from property.

2019: The Year of Rage?

An article republished at JRJ.com goes further and asks if 2019 will be the year of the "defending rights" wave. Homebuyers and speculators giddily poured into developers' sales offices as they bought up property rising 30 percent in a year. They didn't check the quality of the housing or do any research. They threw money at anything and everything amid a speculative fever. The author of the piece below saw his warnings about shoddy construction and inflated prices ignored amid the bubble. Now he expects price cutting could become a real trend into 2019.

JRJ: 碧桂园降价引发业主打砸售楼处 2019全国或上演维权潮
Recently, Anhui has seen a lot of price reduction rights, but there are not many in the country. By the next year, this wave of price reduction will be hit by violent storms. Because once the price reduction trend is formed, it is easy to spread the attitude of buy rising prices and do not buy falling prices. It’s really important to stay calm in the face of the storm.

The pressure on the locality is also very high. The price increase should be controlled for fear of the bubble bursting. The price is lowered and they are afraid of trouble. But I think the market has its own adjustment needs. It will not come about because the owners have more rights to protect the market, or relax the regulation, this is impossible, bowing to a group of people who violate contracts, this is tantamount to encouraging everyone to violate contracts, it is a mess.

I have said before that, as long as the house prices have risen too much, basically the doubling of the market will end, the investment is quickly sold, do not stay in the fishtail market, it is not easy to sell in the sideways, then the long-term will fall, no Markets that only rise or fall will not be absent if they are late.

The fall of the 3rd and 4th lines is not a matter of one or two years, but a slow journey, at least five years and eight years.

First- and second-tier cities will be better. In particular, after this round of the three-fourth line rose, some people cashed in, and they took the money to buy one or two lines. However, it can't escape adjustments, especially those places where the round has risen two or three times, the decline will be even bigger, at least 30%.
Once the sentiment shift takes hold, it will continue even in the face of government rescue efforts. Officially, there is no rescue yet, but one news item from Beijing drew the markets attention: Beijing Loosens Real Estate Regulation. The city did not change policy, for for the first time in two years, it auctioned off a parcel of land with no home price restrictions attached. Evidence of a turn in China's housing market is piling up, but the final piece will be a loosening of real estate restrictions. Only a month ago, analysts were looking for real estate tightening through the end of the 2018 and even into early 2019, with some restrictions never being repealed. The government said it was cracking down on real estate "chaos" and said it would hold local governments accountable if prices keep rising. Contrast all of the above with the myriad of stories posted here over the past three months (see below). Even two weeks ago, there was worry about rising prices: China Real Estate Crackdown: New Home Prices Rise 1.5 pc in August. I expected a turn was coming, but didn't expect it would arrive barely two weeks later.
More likely, this is the final gasp of the boom. China didn't start tightening credit in earnest until after October 2017. First-tier cities aren't seeing a rebound in prices. Lower-tier cities were considered the greater risk in recent years. The government funded renovation projects were designed to slash inventory with bulldozers. The government destroyed too much housing inventory, lower-tier cities did not restrict prices as early as first-tier because of the inventory fear. Lower-tier cities are experiencing the peak of the boom now because government policies gave it one final push before the turn. Price follows volume and sales growth is slowing though, thus eventually the lower-tier cities should cool.

Media Blames Govt Real Estate Controls For New Speculative Bubble
Real Estate Restrictions Boom in May
***The Final Stage: China Copies U.S. Housing Bubble Policies***
China's Housing Mess: Govts Stimulating Demand and Curbing Supply, Fever Rising
China Intensifies Real Estate Controls as Home Prices Climb
PBoC Survey: 23pc of Chinese Plan to Buy a Home in Next 3 Months
***Housing Lottery Frenzy in Shenzhen***
Over 3 Days, 3 Cities Shutdown Commercial Purchases of Homes; A First in China
China Launches 30 City Crackdown on Housing Speculators and Illegal Developers
***China's Upside Down Housing Market***
Housing Chaos in 30 Cities, Crackdown Coming in Second-Half
Rush to Buy New Homes Pushes Prices Up 1.2pc Nationally in July
Chinese Home Prices Soar 1.1pc in June, More Crackdowns Launched
***Fever: Chinese Housing Investment Soars Past 50pc of Total Demand***
Chinese Officials Fear Stimulus Will Ignite Housing Market
***Speculators Take Over Chinese Housing Market***
Ministry of Housing Will Hold Cities Accountable for Failure on Home Prices
Land Market Frozen, Local Govts Have One Mission: Control Home Prices
Cities Begin Tightening Public Housing Funds
Rush to Buy New Homes Pushes Prices Up 1.2pc Nationally in July
Cities Ramp Up Real Estate Regulations Following July Price Rise
Central Planning 101: Blood-Sucking Realtors! The Rent Is Too Damn High!
Government Jawboning Chills Land Market Nationwide in August

2018-10-04

Fed Reduces $18.2 B, USTs Decline $19.0 B

The Federal Reserve did as expected and rolled $19 billion in U.S. treasuries off its balance sheet last week (ended Wednesday). There was a small increase in MBS. The Fed is still running behind on its treasuries (by my count) and now has $38 billion in treasuries to reduce in October, or $30 billion in this month alone. Only $22 billion in treasuries mature on October 31.

The S&P 500 Index gained 19.5 points on the week. QT didn't seem to have an impact. Emerging markets and CNY followed the Fed's balance sheet lower.

The Fed has to reduce $50 billion this month and will reduce $50 per month until it changes policy. Assuming the $22 billion in treasuries rolls off on October 31, that leaves another $28 billion ($8 billion USTs) across 3 weeks.

2018-10-03

1997 Redux: DJIA vs 30-Year Treasury Ratio Soars

1997 was the last time the Dow Jones Industrial Average vs 30-year Treasury bond price ratio was overbought with a strong bullish trend.

Rates Are Peaking or Bond Bear Market Underway

When a long-term market trend turns, there are many different ways to see it. Big moves show in all manner of data, from charts to fundamentals. This is one of the charts I watch for a clear break in bonds: the 100-day moving average on the 30-year Treasury.

The 100-month moving average of the 30-year Treasury yield was broken during the 1994 bond rout, the 2000 market peak, the 2007 market peak, in the 2009 post-crisis reaction period, in 2011. It also came close in 2014. ALL of those moves were reversed within the month.

The 2009 move was a "QE is Weimar" outlier move that came in the wake of a huge market panic. The only other 100-month MA break that didn't lead to a market decline was 1994.

Two points worth keeping in mind:

1. The yield curve is steepening, but not because short-term rates are tumbling. We are in somewhat uncharted territory (have to check history before 1980) because of QE and QT.

2. Europe and China can't follow U.S. rates higher under current economic conditions. The dollar will rise.

2018-10-02

German Social Mood Declining, Greens and AfD Rise

ZH: Merkel's End Could Spark EU Breakdown
As pointed out by Alex Mercouris at The Duran, this is the first time in more than forty years a German Chancellor lost an internal party vote of this magnitude. And it speaks to the growing frustration among not only party members but the German electorate in general.
Immigration is the hot button issue in Germany, but social mood is also turning. The DAX peaked in January. The iShares MSCI Germany ETF (EWG) captures this move along with the weakening euro. Both the Greens and Alterative for Deutschland are rising, while the establishment CDU and SPD see their support wane. This is the start of the move, not the end of it. A major political shake-up is coming to the heart of Europe.

EWG broke above long-term resistance in summer 2017 before rallying into the January 2018 peak, but has since fallen below that resistance line. Notice the rise in the challenger parties as the stock market slides.

For comparison sake, here are two different European funds with similar patterns. France is still in breakout territory, while Spain failed right at resistance.

Non-Anonymous Digital Cash Will Usher in the Age of Extreme Price Discrimination

Everyone should be paying attention to China's social credit system, central bank blockchain efforts and digital payment systems. Chinese consumers are at the forefront of adopting these technologies and the government will maximize the political and economic control made possible by the digital panopticon. The technology and temptation to use it won't stop at China's borders though. Silicon Valley is already implementing social control, censorship and economic controls similar to those in China, but many in the West don't believe it is a threat (libertarians) or support the political ends of Progressive SV companies.

Coverage also tends to focus on draconian powers such as kicking dissidents out of the economy, but there are far more mundane uses such as price discrimination. China's social credit system is designed for price discrimination (such as higher or lower mortgage interest rates), but every transaction between private parties is also open to price discrimination if there's no anonymity. Examples already exist in China's video game market, where game companies have a working model of a non-anonymous economy. They know all the user accounts, how often they play, skill level and also the elasticity of demand. They can raise prices for inelastic users and offer discounts to new players in surreptitious ways such as changing the probability of finding an expensive in-game item.
21st Century: 纸币的未来:发行增速或将放缓,但不具备“消失”条件
He believes that the paperlessness of the currency in the Internet era has greatly stimulated the financial industry. On the one hand, the inflow of cash flow has injected more vitality into the Internet giants, so that these Internet companies can also occupy absolute dominance and advantages in the financial market, and related derivative Internet financial services have also developed rapidly. At the same time, however, Internet platforms such as WeChat and Alipay do not want to replace banknotes because of the popularity of mobile payments. At this stage, if electronic money becomes the only currency to replace banknotes, it will bring more risks in terms of security, currency efficiency, and financial support for entities.

An Internet industry person Liu Jun (pseudonym) pointed out to the 21st Century Business Herald that banknotes are part of the base currency and the best anonymous currency. As far as the current social needs are concerned, even if the banknotes disappear, new anonymous currencies must appear. If every transaction can be electronicized and digitized, it may lead to new problems, such as consumption and even social injustice.

Liu Jun specifically pointed out that taking a well-known game operator as an example, many players have similar doubts. Players who do not recharge often have a higher probability of getting a higher discount when clicking on a discount, while a player who often re-ups usually has a lower probability when clicking on a discount. It is almost impossible to buy goods in physical offline stores, but online virtual products are very common in the game industry, and even more direct price discrimination.

“For example, in many games, the 'forging' mode tells the player that you need to buy the 'parts' and get a complete item through a certain number of forgings. The system can control the number of forgings in the background, such as the novice player can forge three times and can be successful, the 'pro' player has to forge 10 times to be successful, so that the final price can be controlled and become targeted price discrimination," he said.

Liu Jun told reporters that the current electronic money is not anonymous. With the development of big data, everyone's spending power and consumer psychology are accurately positioned and analyzed. This is essentially behind the promotion of consumption upgrading. An embodiment of inequality. When the merchants have accumulated enough user data, they can carry out price discrimination. In some online shopping platforms, the status quo has been different for different consumers and different products. If there is no good technology and system to balance and limit, if the banknotes disappear, it may also bring about the retrogression of precious metals to replace the banknotes.
But make sure you pay cash for your gold, otherwise there will be a digital record of the transaction...

2018-10-01

Turn Confirmed: Beijing Loosens Real Estate Regulation

Barely three months after the government launched a rhetorical and regulatory crackdown on the "chaotic" housing market, the first sign of regulatory easing has appeared.

Although it isn't a policy change, the Beijing municipal govertment sold a plot of land without restrictions on the housing sale price for the first time in 2 years.

iFeng: 不限价商品房地块重现北京 限竟房时代开始谢幕?
On September 29th, the reporter of China Times reported on the website of the Beijing Municipal Bureau of Land Planning that of 17 pre-applied residential plots that were hanged on the same day, for the first time in 2 years one plot had no restrictions on home prices.

The reporter saw on the website of the Municipal Planning Commission that among the 17 plots, 13 were home price restricted plots, 3 were shared property rights plots, and only 1 had no set price limit. The plot is located at No. 0517-L02, Nanyuan Pomegranate, Fengtai District, Beijing. The planned construction area is 63,070 square meters and the starting price is 2.587 billion yuan. The plot will build about 10,440 square meters of public transportation facilities and 300 social parking spaces, and will be equipped with institutional pension facilities, community cultural facilities and post offices.

This is the first time since Beijing adopted the “price limit for land price” policy in October 2016. After 24 months, Beijing has once again seen residential plots that do not qualify the price of commercial housing in the land supply chain.
First-tier cities started tightening early in the cycle and lower-tier cities still haven't matched their policies. If this is a first step toward easing in the top-tier, we should still see lower-tier cities tighten for months yet.

Regulators are always slow moving and behind the curve. In the prior downturns they first lifted restrictions and then swung to stimulus because sentinent shifted. They do the same on the way up. The "chatotic" market and a major crackdown from on high came during the melt-up phase. Sentiment dominates at the extremes in mood. It defies everything thrown at it, leaving policymakers flat-footed because the miss the turn. Beijing is the first city to notice the policy overshoot.