2009-10-23

Tracking the Chinese real estate bubble

A link to this site landed in my inbox: Beijing Anjuke. It has rents and apartment prices all over Beijing. Google Life is another good site which has many Chinese cities. You can check out rents or prices for new and existing apartments. Here are Google translate links for Anjuke and Google Life for you lazy illiterates out there.

One thing that pops out is that you can rent a place for very reasonable prices, but buying is very expensive—a situation that has lasted at least as long as decade.

2009-10-22

Socionomics Watch—Wolfman

On page 10 of Pioneering Studies in Socionomics, Prechter is in the midst of discussing horror movies and bear markets. After mentioning the string of hits in the early 1930s, he goes on to say:
Ironically, Hollywood tried to introduce a new monster in 1935 during a bull market, but Werewolf of London was a flop. When film makers tried again in 1941, in the depths of a bear market, The Wolf Man was a smash hit.
The Wolfman
In theaters: February 12, 2010.
Inspired by the classic Universal film that launched a legacy of horror, The Wolfman brings the myth of a cursed man back to its iconic origins. Oscar® winner Benicio Del Toro stars as Lawrence Talbot, a haunted nobleman lured back to his family estate after his brother vanishes. Reunited with his estranged father (Oscar® winner Anthony Hopkins), Talbot sets out to find his brother…and discovers a horrifying destiny for himself.

2009-10-21

Let's get contrarian

Robert Prechter is probably the most famous dollar bull. Now let's add Ambrose Evans-Pritchard to the list. He has his own arguments in: Dollar hegemony for another century
Let me stick my neck out.

The dollar will still be the world’s dominant reserve currency in 2030, sharing a degree of leadership in uneasy condominium with the Chinese yuan. It will then regain much of its hegemonic status as the 21st century unfolds. It may indeed end the century even stronger than it was at the start.

The aging crisis in Asia — and indeed the outright demographic implosion in Japan and China, not to mention China’s water crisis — will soon be obvious to everybody. Talk of Oriental supremacy will start to sound overblown at first, and then preposterous.
He cites European and Asian demographics, and the currently weak U.S. dollar. He does add the caveat that Obama and the Dems could totally destroy a strong economic recovery that may be building in the United States with their reckless spending.

One thing is that all the notes he hits are facts. When the dollar recovers, suddenly it will be obvious that Europe and Japan are in worse shape, that China's yuan is not ready to take on the U.S. dollar, etc.

For the opposite view, see Niall Ferguson's interviews.

Crash Comparison 2009/10/21


OTB Portfolio Update 2009/10/21

Fannie (FNM) and Freddie (FRE) had big rebounds and pulled the portfolio into positive territory, up 1.57% on the day. OTB Portfolio down 14.64% since inception.

The Fed's Mexican Standoff

Mish Shedlock highlights a Carolyn Baum article in Fed Sponsored Feedback Loops and the Fed Uncertainty Principle Revisited. Here's an excerpt from Baum's article, Bernanke Frets Over Sherlock Holmes’s Next Stop.
If I have this right, we’re waiting for the Fed to do or say something to help us decide whether we should hoard cash (because we expect the dollar to buy more tomorrow if prices are falling) or buy and hoard hard goods (if we expect inflation to diminish the dollar’s purchasing power).

The Fed, in turn, is waiting for us to do something so it can decide what to do: either raise the volume on its anti- inflation rhetoric with talk of exit strategies and price stability; or talk softly to allay fears of premature rate increases to keep market rates from rising.

This is hard enough for your average MBA graduate on Wall Street to understand. And the Fed expects the average Joe on the auto-assembly or unemployment line to have a well-formulated view of inflation expectations?

It’s not that people aren’t rational; they are. It’s that they lack perfect information.
Baum's main point is that the Fed creates inflation. Period. Full stop. The public cannot create inflation because the public doesn't control the money supply. (There are some who believe money creation by the Fed backfills the credit creation by private firms, which widens this debate, but I'll ignore that for now because the Fed can always refuse to print money.)

Baum focuses on the public view of inflation, who have a tenuous at best grasp of inflation and the current inflation rate. I'm more interested in the financial markets view. The smart money is watching the Fed to see if it will inflate or deflate, while the Fed is watching them to see if they hoard dollars or hoard assets. It results in a Mexican standoff with both sides waiting for the other to move.

In any event, I don't see how the Fed can pursue a "sane" policy of inflation with everyone watching, since it would drive up commodity prices and interest rates beyond their "equilibrium" as it created new bubbles, which would then lead to another crash as the Fed tried to tame "inflation expectations", or simply by the higher prices acting as a tax on consumers, as we saw with the oil bubble in 2008.

Socionomics Watch—Political Discontent

Check out the Rasmussen poll numbers:
he Rasmussen Reports daily Presidential Tracking Poll for Wednesday shows that 27% of the nation's voters Strongly Approve of the way that Barack Obama is performing his role as President. Forty percent (40%) Strongly Disapprove giving Obama a Presidential Approval Index rating of -13. That’s just a point above the lowest level ever recorded for this President. It’s also the sixth straight day in negative double digits, matching the longest such streak.

Just 31% of voters believe that Congress has a good understanding of the health care proposal.

Thirty-nine percent (39%) of Republicans have a favorable opinion of their party’s national chairman, Michael Steele.

The Presidential Approval Index is calculated by subtracting the number who Strongly Disapprove from the number who Strongly Approve.

Overall, 47% of voters say they at least somewhat approve of the President's performance. Fifty-three percent (53%) disapprove.
Neither party has attempted to tap voter anger because they do not agree with the policy implications. This suggests an outsider has a shot at the presidency in 2012. And if Prechter is right on his wave calls, these numbers will look awesomely good in a year or two.

2009-10-20

OTB Portfolio Update 2009/10/20

I should have updated the Obama-Turbo-Bernanke special in the past few days because there was some great action in Fannie (FNM) and Freddie (FRE). They're both down close to 40% now, since inception. AIG remains on top, the only fund in positive territory, with a 7% gain since inception.

Today, the portfolio lost 2.71%, and is down 15.96% since inception.

Crash Comparison Update 2009/10/20


Niall Ferguson on the American Empire & US$



Brazil joins Southeast Asia in dollar support

Two weeks ago, Southeast Asian nations stepped up their dollar support. Now Brazil is trying to stop the rise of its currency:
Forex Effect From Brazil Tax Move Could Prove Short-Lived
Monday night, Finance Minister Guido Mantega announced a 2% tax on foreign portfolio investments into fixed-income and equities accounts.

Mr. Mantega stated frankly that the purpose of the move was to support the U.S. dollar against the surging Brazilian currency, the real. A strong real, he said, was "threatening local companies."

That threat comes partly from cheap imports, which soak up market share among Brazilian consumers, and partly from exports made less competitive by a strong local currency.
These efforts will fail because the central banks cannot control the market, no matter what they believe. The real story is that for all the inevitability of a weaker dollar, there is a lot of dollar support. What are the chances of a miscalculation?

Also, with respect to currencies, please see this David Einhorn speech to the Value Investing Congress. ZeroHedge plucked out several gems, but the one below is the most important and why I believe precious metals and hard assets are the best choice for anyone concerned about a weak dollar:

The failure of Lehman meant that barring extraordinary measures, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs would have failed as the credit market realized that if the government were willing to permit failures, then the cost of financing such institutions needed to be re-priced so as to invalidate their business models.

I believe there is a real possibility that the collapse of any of the major currencies could have a similar domino effect on re-assessing the credit risk of the other fiat currencies run by countries with structural deficits and large, unfunded commitments to aging populations.

Einhorn Vic 2009 Speech

Another view of the rally

Here's the SPDR S&P 500 Index (SPY) divided by PowerShares DB U.S. Dollar Bearish (UDN)

Here's the SPY divided by CurrencyShares Australian Dollar (FXA)

Here's the SPY divided WisdomTree Emerging Market Currency (CEW). Much shorter time-frame because CEW issued in the spring.

Here's the SPY divided by SPDR Gold Shares (GLD). Notice the weak trendline.

2009-10-16

Crash Comparison Update 2009/10/16



Divergences all over.

幸运眷顾中国,但真实吗?谢国忠

Andy Xie's latest: Fortune is favouring China, but is it due for a reality check?
The United States had 1929, Japan 1989 and south-east Asia 1997. Will China face a similar moment of reckoning a few years from now?


The question is crucial, not just for those investing in Asia today but for the wider global market. For as investors around the world reel from the recent financial crisis, many have clung to the idea of a Chinese boom as the one bright spot of hope in an otherwise grim world. The trouble is that history suggests that much of this optimism may be misplaced.


Financial markets have a way of working themselves into a frenzy during rapid economic development, which ends up leading to disaster. It is the ultimate testimony to the gross inefficiency of markets. The problem is the unique mix of extreme optimism and rampant liquidity that occurs during periods of rapid economic development.


Economic development, especially in a large country such as China, generates exceptional optimism for many reasons. Nothing brings out the animal spirits in humans like watching the economic pie expanding. And it is natural to buy risk assets such as stocks to express one’s optimism over the future. The problem is that market competition tends to depress capital returns and give the fruits of economic development to workers and consumers rather than investors. High asset prices incentivize companies to over-invest, which depresses returns on capital. This is why investors tend to do poorly during periods of rapid economic growth.


A low income base and favourable demographics help promote successful economic development. Both tend to lead to excess liquidity due to a high savings rate on incremental income growth. When a population is urbanising, even though its productivity is shifting from the agricultural to the industrial level, consumption habits remain rural – that is, anything beyond necessities is viewed as luxury and is minimised. The widening gap between the labour productivity increase and the consumption preference leads to the excess liquidity that feeds bubbles.


China's one-child policy brings the ultimate demographic dividend but probably makes the country the most bubble-prone in modern times. The situation is made worse by the revenue dependency of local governments on the property market. Local government officials, who change every five years or so, have strong incentives to juice up the property market to maximise their revenues. This political incentive sows the seed for a great property bubble.


Similarly, China's stock market will remain overvalued, although it will deflate from time to time during panics and temporary liquidity shortages. The combination of low returns on capital and high share prices means businesses turn to the stock market rather than to their customers for profit.


But when businesses make profits from, rather than for, the stock market, it becomes a negative sum game. It needs continuing liquidity inflows to sustain it. This is why high growth and a high savings rate are vital.


On the other hand, such a market essentially subsidises capital formation. The capital subsidy leads to overcapacity and low returns on capital. This is why poor profitability, high asset prices and high economic growth rates can coexist. Indeed, they must exist together.


China's economic development is undoubtedly going to be the most important economic event for the next decade or two. But the semi-permanent bubble situation makes it extremely difficult for financial investors to participate in this story. “Buy and hold” simply won’t work. Value investing doesn’t work because value investors base their decisions on price/earnings ratios and price/book value ratios falling below certain levels.


Chinese stocks never get there. If you are Warren Buffett, you can create your own bubble. He recently bought a stake in BYD, an aspiring maker of electric cars. The stock has since risen eight times. If you are not Warren Buffett, I suggest “buy low, sell high”. The problem is working out what is high and what is low.


The day of reckoning will come when the high economic growth rate finally falters. This could happen either when the favourable demographic trend worsens or urbanisation ends. When either or both occurs, liquidity or savings do not grow any more. At that point, the stock market cannot be subsidised any more.


China’s final day of reckoning is probably 10 years away.


By that time, half of China’s babyboomers who were born between 1950 and 1978 will have retired. And the Chinese urbanisation rate will be OVER 70%. The good news is that China will be a developed country by then. The bad news is that there will be no cheap money for supporting overvalued asset prices any more.
The takeaway is that investors won't be able to buy and hold, but 10 years is plenty of time to make money.

2009-10-15

U.S. Recovery or Reserve Currency, Choose One

I hadn't written this out into a blogpost, but I notice Martin Wolf and apparently Fred Bergsten agree with my conclusion, which is that the United States cannot recover and maintain its reserve currency status.
The rumours of the dollar's death are much exaggerated
Most analysts assume that the US fiscal position can be determined independently of decisions taken elsewhere. But if the US private sector were to deleverage over a long period (and so spend substantially less than its income), while the rest of the world wanted to accumulate dollar-denominated assets as reserves, the US government would naturally emerge as the borrower of last resort. A corollary of the Triffin dilemma is that the international role of the dollar could make it hard for the US to manage its fiscal affairs successfully, even if it wanted to do so.

I arrive, by a somewhat different route, at the same conclusion as Mr Bergsten: the global role of the dollar is not in the interests of the US. The case for moving to a different system is very strong. This is not because the dollar's role is now endangered. It is rather because it impairs domestic and global stability. The time for alternatives is now.
U.S. reserve currency status led to the imbalances that helped create and exacerbate the financial crisis. The U.S. cannot restructure until it gives up reserve currency status, but the political implications are huge and Washington doesn't want to give up its power.

2009-10-14

Crash Comparison Update 2009/10/14


Socionomics Watch—Anger

Rage at Government for Doing Too Much and Not Enough Left and right always disagree about what the government should do, but now both of them hate government and business. Voters are still ignorant though, for instance they are angry about the deficit, but also oppose Medicare cuts or want government-run healthcare.

How about a September 2009 October 2009 Comparison


I noticed the day-by-day was repeating.

Crash Comparison Update 2009/10/13

October 13 was the initial target date. This chart is now exhausted. I'll keep updating it for comparison though.

2009-10-12

Baosteel Deflation—宝钢通货紧缩

In September, Baosteel cut October prices. (宝钢下调10月钢价)
In October, Baosteel is cutting November prices:
Baosteel Group, the parent of Baoshan Iron & Steel Co., cut its prices of steel products for November delivery by 250 to 500 yuan per ton from October, a company official told Caijing on Oct. 12.

The country's biggest steelmaker cut medium steel plate prices by 400 yuan per ton, and cut the price of cold and hot rolled steel by 400 to 500 yuan a ton, the official said.

The special 100 to 300 yuan discounts on hot and cold steel plate for October orders was extended.
宝钢11月碳钢出厂价格继续下调
10月10日,宝钢出台钢产品11月新价格政策。在10月价格基础上,中厚板价格普遍下调400元/吨;热轧品种中普碳钢价格下调400元/吨,机械用钢等品种钢价格下调500元/吨,增加优惠100元/吨;酸洗价格下调250元/吨,增加优惠300元/吨;冷轧及热镀锌的价格普遍下调400元/吨,同时分别增加优惠300元/吨和200元/吨。其中,普碳钢和酸洗的价格是继10月下调之后继续深调。
通货紧缩.