2018-09-18

Trade War Lessons from Ancient China

Ancient Chinese history provides a lesson about bubble, malinvestment and trade wars. A legend called 种桑误国 describes how minister Guan Zhong of Qi conquered the neighboring countries. It says the minister ordered everyone to wear silk, but forbid the domestic production of silk (no planting of mulberry trees). All farmland was to be used for food production. The price of silk soared and the neighboring countries planted many mulberry trees and shifted into silk production. They became wealthy exporting silk. Then Guan Zhong ordered all of the ministers to stop wearing silk and cut off food exports. Faced with starvation, people fled to Qi. In this way, Qi easily conquered its neighbors.

The legend may have grown from a real event, the war with Hengshan.
In the record of Guanzi Chapter 84, Duke of Huan wanted to restrain the threat from State of Hengshan(衡山国)and asked Guan for solution. State of Hengshan was famous for its weapon production. Guan then ordered officials to buy arms from State of Hengshan in large quantities. After ten months, worrying that the price will continuously grow up, State of Yan, State of Dai and later State of Qin followed up the buying. The price then jumped sharply and, as a result, almost all household in State of Hengshan switched to make weapons instead of farming. One year later, Guan ordered officials to buy rice from State of Zhao, at a price more than three times higher than normal. By seeing the potential huge profit, State of Hengshan sold its rice inventory to officials from State of Qi. Afterwards, Guan suddenly ordered State of Qi's army to invade State of Hengshan. With selling out of weapon and rice, State of Hengshan soon surrendered.
Trade wars are often thought of in terms of kinetic wars. Both sides take losses, each side fights using direct attacks such as blocking trade. A more thorough form of economic destruction requires a long setup using passive strategies. Guan Zhong was a Machiavellian Austrian economist. He wasted money on weapons and rice to draw the enemy into unproductive economic activities. Right until the military invasion, the Fake News of ancient China might have written untold articles about the stupidity of Guan Zhong and the wealthy rising economic power of Hengshan.

Who is Qi today? Both China and the USA cause more economic destruction internally with debt-fueled housing and financial bubbles. Longer-term, both countries are their own worst enemy. In the short-term, a straight comparison of the trade relationship argues for the USA. China is more fragile not simply because trade is a larger share of GDP, but because it is dependent on U.S. demand. Chinese factories do not make goods for Chinese consumers. They serve U.S. customers. The immediate impact of a full-blown trade war in the USA is empty shelves at Wal-Mart and changing consumption patterns. The immediate impact in China is unemployment and factory closures. (If China had a credible currency and debt market alternative, it might qualify as Qi because it could pull the plug on the dollar. But it doesn't, not yet and probably not for at least 10 years.) President Trump has inelegantly described this situation as America having already lost the trade war. The more perspicacious Steve Bannon understands America's "weaknesses" leave it in a momentary position of strength. Steve Bannon even channels Guan Zhong: We Can Take the Whole Thing Down, Total Victory for USA

A more subtle lesson from Guan Zhong is the power of consumption. Trade wars are focused on production, but it is through consumption (yin) that victory was achieved in part because everyone focuses on production (yang). The consumer has the greater soft power because the producer serves the consumer.The people of the United States have made much of China into an extension of the U.S. economy because those factories operate to serve U.S. customers. China's chief representative if WTO accession negotiations understands this deeper truth. He argues China should increase its imports because that is what made America so powerful.

iFeng: 龙永图:美国为什么那么牛?因为它是全球最大的进口国
Why is the United States so powerful? Think about it, come out one - it is the world's largest importer!

As the chief representative of China's WTO accession negotiations, Long Yongtu judged the significant contribution of imports to the US economy. He believes that the importing country has largely determined the price and determined the market. This is "the dream of all of us who engage in foreign trade." Therefore, the entrepreneurs and the government are called upon to give greater attention to imports . Just as President Xi’s positive import increase to the Boao Forum is an important measure for our new opening up, we should do this in accordance with the requirements of President Xi!

Under the global economic situation, our global trading system is still “cutting and chaos”, what should we do? The United States has repeatedly threatened to "retreat the group" and Long Yongtu said, "I hope it will not be retired, and don't be afraid of it." Why is the United States "bullish"? How can China, as the world's second largest economy, be invincible in global trade?

...So what kind of policy choices can we make based on such a chaotic and very complicated global trading system? What should we do in China? Long Yongtu proposed two options for this:

First, continue to support the global system represented by the World Trade Organization and the threat of US withdrawal from the WTO. Take a positive attitude: I hope it doesn't quit, and don't be afraid to quit it.

Second, on the basis of continuing to support the WTO global system, we will participate more actively in global regional trade arrangements. One of the most important things is how to speed up regional trade negotiations in Asia.

For our trade policy, we should pay equal attention to both exports and imports, and we should increase our efforts to increase imports.
Lou Jiwei takes an opposite approach from Guan Zhong, proposing a yang strategy instead of yin:
Caixin: Chinese official: Beijing should target goods needed by US
Speaking Sunday at an economics forum, Lou said Beijing should disrupt supply chains of American companies that rely on China's vast manufacturing industries, the website Sina.com reported.

China's "counterattack strategy needs to restrict exports to the United States as well as (imports of) U.S. goods," Lou was paraphrased as saying.

"Only knowing the pain of fighting will stop the war and cause (the United States) to negotiate seriously," said Lou.

Lou was finance minister through 2016 and serves as chairman of China's 1.9 trillion yuan ($290 billion) National Social Security Fund, which manages assets of government pension plans. He is a former chairman of China's sovereign wealth fund, the China Investment Corp.
Lou Jiwei's approach plays into Trump's hands. As long as the U.S. is willing to accept the pain, it would accelerate the movement of supply chains out of China and into politically secure jurisdictions. The genius of Guan Zhong was in appearing weak and making the enemy believe he was strong (and rich). China has been running a strategy similar to Guan Zhong for 20 years, mainly because the United States was being looted by its financial and political establishment. That regime is losing power and China isn't sure what to do. It has been courting its old Wall Street allies, but their power has waned.

NYTimes: As Trump’s Trade War Mounts, China’s Wall Street Allies Lose Clout
When President Bill Clinton deliberated whether he should loosen trade barriers against China, Wall Street helped plead Beijing’s case.

When Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama talked tough about labeling China as a currency manipulator, Wall Street urged restraint — and both presidents backed down.

Today, China is hoping that Wall Street will once again use its political heft to soothe tempers in Washington. But as President Trump ratchets up the trade war with Beijing, Wall Street’s words are falling on deaf ears.

Senior Wall Street executives met in Beijing on Sunday with current and former Chinese officials and bankers at a hastily organized session to find ways to strengthen financial ties between the United States and China. On Monday, the group — which included executives from Goldman Sachs Group, Morgan Stanley and the Blackstone Group, the private equity firm, among others — planned to meet with Vice President Wang Qishan, the right hand man of Xi Jinping, the country’s leader.
As I wrote back in 2014:
The protectionists are ever so slowly gaining the upper hand thanks in part to negative social mood. 2008-2009 will probably mark the peak moment for Wall Street and the Treasury Department, even though there is as yet no sign of it in Washington. Changes can be seen in the form of issues such as immigration, which has turned the grassroots of the conservative movement against the Chamber of Commerce and large corporations (due to an attack initiated by the latter against the former). This has pushed the Overton window of acceptable debate among conservatives who can now take shots at big business. There is also the growing libertarian faction pulled together by Ron Paul that supports his son, Rand Paul, that consistently attacks the Federal Reserve and Wall Street. Put it together and it is not hard to envision an anti-Wall Street, pro-manufacturing political consensus emerging. This will cut across party lines, with manufacturing unions pulling in Democratic support if there are specific bills to vote on.
The alliance grows stronger by the day.

If China wants things to "return to normal" it needs Trump gone and populism ended. Then it can get back to the old strategy with Wall Street as its witting partner and Washington its unwitting partner. Next best is getting back to its grand strategy: lulling the world into a slumber as it peacefully rises. China's Made in 2025 initiative and military expansion in the South China Sea came too early. A renewed focus on economic development is needed.

What can China do to mollify Trump? The CCP doesn't want an open the economy, it has been ratcheting up its control. It would have already granted its own citizens greater economic freedom if this was an acceptable solution. Thus, the only politically acceptable option that will get China back on its long-term track is greatly increased imports. And if they study Guan Zhong, they would know that's the best way to fight an economic war.

Being Weimar

European governments are paving the way for nationalist victories in the coming years.

ZH: Netherlands Prosceutes Its Own Citizen For Calling Turkish Dictator A "Goat F*cker"
Case in point: a few weeks ago the government of the Netherlands charged and prosecuted one of its own citizens, a 64-year old Dutchman from the town of Sittard near the German border, for sending angry emails to the President of Turkey.

You read that correctly. The Dutch government prosecuted a Dutch citizen living on Dutch soil because he insulted a foreign government official.

Bear in mind, that foreign government official is Recep Erdogan, who has basically been dictator of Turkey since the early 2000s.
The Guardian: China accuses Sweden of violating human rights over treatment of tourists
A disagreement between Chinese tourists and a hostel in Stockholm over check-in time has turned into a diplomatic spat between China and Sweden, after Beijing criticised Sweden for violating the human rights of Chinese citizens.

China has demanded an apology from Sweden and issued a safety alert for its tourists in the country after it said that three tourists had been “brutally abused” by Swedish police on 2 September.
There's more detail and context here: All the details you need on the Chinese tourists who were ”brutally” handled by Swedish police. Sweden hasn't acted badly. The tourists look like they're acting, trying to get money or maybe a free room. It's China's response that shows what it thinks of the Swedish government: a pushover.

2018-09-16

Home Equity Lending Grows in First-tier, Critical Credit Source for SMEs

Caijing: 一线城市住房抵押贷款经营类利率下行 消费类此消彼长
...A customer manager of CITIC Bank's personal loan department told 21st Century Business Herald that since last year, CITIC Bank's personal home mortgage loan has experienced a process from loose to tight, and then to the current interest rate easing.

“In 2017, we put a lot of mortgage loans. By the end of February this year, we received a notice to suspend the mortgage loan of more than 2 million, and the loan interest rate also rose to over 7.03%. However, after July The funds are relatively loose. Although the current mortgage loan amount can't exceed 2 million yuan, the interest rate can be about 6.3%, but it is expected that there will be some relaxation in the fourth quarter. However, the mortgage consumer interest rate is still maintained at 7%. about."

..."At present, we are still relatively active in operating loans. Now this home loan fast loan product is a convenient financing channel for small and micro enterprises engaged in entity management. The current interest rate is about 6.7%. The credit is for three years and can be recycled. After a full week, the loan will be released. In addition, there is a 20-year repayment of the product, and the interest rate is around 7%."

...In fact, for private small micro-entities enterprises and individual industrial and commercial households with low technological content, it is still the most important financing method to obtain personal financing through shareholders and controllers. A person in charge of a textile company in Shandong told the 21st Century Business Herald reporter that although it has always said that it wants to support small and micro enterprises, for us, mortgage real estate is almost the only way to obtain loans, and credit loans are difficult to obtain.

A deputy governor of a state-owned bank in the Pearl River Delta region told the 21st Century Economic Reporter that banks have relaxed mortgage operating loans and also considered to support small and micro enterprises. "As long as the funds really enter the real economy, they will not raise the real estate prices and promote the bubble."

2018-09-15

China Real Estate Crackdown: New Home Prices Rise 1.5 pc in August

China was in the midst of an historic real estate tightening cycle that quickly intensified after May. The Politburo made real estate controls a focus, local officials are warned they will be held accountable for rising prices and cities have stepped up their regulations. While the land market showed signs of cooling in August, new home prices have yet to react. Instead, price increases have accelerated over the past few months. June, July and now August have seen prices rise 1.1, 1.2 and 1.5 percent nationally.

The worst case scenario is China has lost control of the real estate market. As limited as the stimulus has been, it is flowing into a very restricted housing market. Some analysts have argued that demand has been suppressed for so long that it is finally coming back despite intensifying restrictions. Restrictions are also a bullish signal for speculators because every round of real estate tightening leads to an overshoot. Speculators started dominating the real estate market in late 2017. If the median home sales is still going to speculators, prices will keep rising as speculators chase an ever dwindling supply. Homebuyers may also be chasing prices if they fear even higher prices.

More likely, this is the final gasp of the boom. China didn't start tightening credit in earnest until after October 2017. First-tier cities aren't seeing a rebound in prices. Lower-tier cities were considered the greater risk in recent years. The government funded renovation projects were designed to slash inventory with bulldozers. The government destroyed too much housing inventory, lower-tier cities did not restrict prices as early as first-tier because of the inventory fear. Lower-tier cities are experiencing the peak of the boom now because government policies gave it one final push before the turn. Price follows volume and sales growth is slowing though, thus eventually the lower-tier cities should cool.

For now, the government is stepping up real estate controls. Even in cities such as Beijing, where new and existing home prices were flat in August.

21st Century: 史上最严公积金贷款新政背后:楼市酝酿深度调整
On the evening of September 13, the Beijing Housing Provident Fund Management Center issued the "Notice on Adjusting the Housing Provident Fund Personal Housing Loan Policy" (hereinafter referred to as the "Notice"). Compared with previous policies, in addition to simplifying the procedures, several adjustments to the Notice will have a major impact on market trends: First, since September 17, online purchases will be executed when using the provident fund loans. Second, in the future, the provident fund loan will be linked to the payment period. Each deposit can be borrowed for 100,000 yuan a year, and the deposit for 12 years can be loaned to the highest of 1.2 million yuan. Third, The provident fund loan is also adjusted for the down payment ratio. The first set of ordinary self-occupied first payment ratios other than policy-oriented housing is not less than 35%, and the down payment ratio of the first non-ordinary self-occupied housing is not less than 40%. For the purchase of ordinary self-occupied housing and the second set of housing, the down payment ratio is not less than 60%; for the purchase of non-ordinary self-occupied housing and the second set of housing, the down payment ratio is not less than 80%. After the adjustment, the down payment ratio of the provident fund loans and commercial loans is basically the same.

21st Century: 8月楼市“高温”背后: 库存降至4年新低 房企追求现金流
Since the beginning of this year, the real estate market has maintained the momentum of both supply and demand. Some institutional analysts believe that this is because the supply and demand fundamentals of many cities have changed. On the one hand, after three years of “de-stocking”, the overall inventory size of the country has dropped significantly, and the inventory of some cities is significantly lower than normal; on the other hand, the demand that has been suppressed by the regulatory policies for a long time is seeking to be released.

Does this fundamental mean that the market still has the momentum to rise, and it still needs to be observed. However, from the changes in some details, the impact of regulatory policies has begun to appear: strong investment, improved work, and a decline in monthly sales.
Sales growth is losing momentum:
According to the National Bureau of Statistics, from January to August this year, the sales area of ​​commercial housing in the country was 102.474 million square meters, up 4.0% year-on-year; the sales of commercial housing was 8.9396 billion yuan, up 14.5%. Since May this year, the sales amount has maintained a double-digit growth.

From the perspective of regional distribution, the central and western regions are still the key areas for sales. Zhongyuan Real Estate believes that this is due to the “peak period of the third- and fourth-tier cities, such as shed reforms, which still exist”.

However, from the data of the single month in August, the situation does not seem so optimistic. In August, the sales growth of commercial housing in the country was 2.4% year-on-year, and the chain was narrowed by 7.5 percentage points, indicating that the transaction heat in August was lower than that in July.

Reuters: Growth in Chinese home prices accelerates to two-year high
Average new home prices in China’s 70 major cities rose 1.4 percent in August from a month earlier, higher than July’s reading of 1.1 percent, Reuters calculated from an official survey published on Saturday.

That marks the fastest gain since September 2016, and the 40th straight month of price increases, Reuters calculations show, despite tougher curbs designed to rein in a near-three-year real estate boom that has spilled over from megacities to the hinterland.

In a sign of broadening market strength, 67 out of the 70 cities surveyed by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) reported a monthly price increase for new homes, up from 65 in July. Only one city - Xiamen in the south - had an actual price decline.

Compared with a year ago, new home prices climbed 7 percent, speeding up from July’s 5.8 percent rise, the NBS data showed.

“Property price gains this year are due to looser credit and the delayed effect of strong government stimulus introduced in previous months to reduce inventories, which will slowly kick in,” said Nie Wen, an analyst at Hwabao Trust.


...While many property analysts believe authorities will be more cautious about stimulating property investment than in past downturns, some suspect additional funds will inevitably flow into the market as investors look for opportunities.
SCMP: China’s home prices rise at fastest rate for 2 years
New-home prices gained 1.49 per cent from the previous month, according to Bloomberg calculations based on data for 70 cities released by the National Bureau of Statistics on Saturday. That compared with a 1.2 per cent increase in July. It was the sixth straight monthly acceleration.

Of the 70 cities, the biggest month-on-month price increase in August was a 3.4 per cent gain in Wuxi, the data showed. In Beijing, where more tightening was announced on Thursday, prices were unchanged; in Shanghai, they were up 0.1 per cent.

The government is likely to maintain property curbs, based on fears that any relaxation will lead to another round of price surges, Haibin Zhu, the chief China economist at JPMorgan Chase, said ahead of the data. Officials are seeking to keep housing affordable and limit the risk of destabilising bubbles.

Here's coverage of real estate going back to April, in chronological order of posting.

Chinese Home Price Rise Accelerates in April
***Central Planning 101: Housing "Shortages", Price Distortions Appear as Cities Limit Prices***
Media Blames Govt Real Estate Controls For New Speculative Bubble
Real Estate Restrictions Boom in May
***The Final Stage: China Copies U.S. Housing Bubble Policies***
China's Housing Mess: Govts Stimulating Demand and Curbing Supply, Fever Rising
China Intensifies Real Estate Controls as Home Prices Climb
PBoC Survey: 23pc of Chinese Plan to Buy a Home in Next 3 Months
***Housing Lottery Frenzy in Shenzhen***
Over 3 Days, 3 Cities Shutdown Commercial Purchases of Homes; A First in China
China Launches 30 City Crackdown on Housing Speculators and Illegal Developers
***China's Upside Down Housing Market***
Housing Chaos in 30 Cities, Crackdown Coming in Second-Half
Rush to Buy New Homes Pushes Prices Up 1.2pc Nationally in July
Chinese Home Prices Soar 1.1pc in June, More Crackdowns Launched
***Fever: Chinese Housing Investment Soars Past 50pc of Total Demand***
Chinese Officials Fear Stimulus Will Ignite Housing Market
***Speculators Take Over Chinese Housing Market***
Ministry of Housing Will Hold Cities Accountable for Failure on Home Prices
Land Market Frozen, Local Govts Have One Mission: Control Home Prices
Cities Begin Tightening Public Housing Funds
Rush to Buy New Homes Pushes Prices Up 1.2pc Nationally in July
Cities Ramp Up Real Estate Regulations Following July Price Rise
Central Planning 101: Blood-Sucking Realtors! The Rent Is Too Damn High!
Government Jawboning Chills Land Market Nationwide in August

2018-09-14

Real Estate Investment Stable, State Fixed Asset Investment Contracts Again

Chinese Companies Buying Back Stock to Avoid Pledged Loan Margin Calls

Stock buybacks in China may be less about buying low and more about CEOs and major shareholders avoiding margin calls.
SCMP: Bottom-fishing investors should rethink when Chinese companies start buying back their shares
An easy and obvious solution is to prop up the company’s shares with buy-backs. In contrast to their US counterparts, Chinese investors are right to be wary. In the second half, a staggering 1 trillion yuan of share-pledged loans will be due. A similar amount of corporate bonds will need to be refinanced, forcing these companies to compete for funding.

2018-09-13

Fed Increased Balance Sheet $2.3 Billion

The S&P 500 Index increased 0.32 points in the past week, in which the Fed increased its balance sheet by $2.3 billion, nearly all of it MBS. The Fed has $37.1 billion left in September.

Beijing Fines 我爱我家 and Beijing Zhongtian For Renting Public Housing

Two real estate brokers rented out public housing.

iFeng: 我爱我家、中天置地在京转租公租房被罚
The Beijing Municipal Housing and Construction Committee released the results of the sub-leasing behavior of the Greentown Chengyuan Public Rental Housing Project on September 12. I love my family and Zhongtian Land, both brokerage companies have illegally rented public rental housing. The behavior was fined at a ceiling of 60,000 yuan each, and was credited to the credit file, suspending the two intermediary companies to sign online in Chaoyang District. At the same time, the four households rented outholding leases for illegal households were dismissed, and the “Decision on Cancellation of the Qualification of Safe Housing” was incorporated into the bad credit system.

...On September 3, Chaoyang District Housing Management Bureau talked about the person in charge of my family and Zhongtian Real Estate Agency, and issued a notice of punishment. On September 7th, the two brokerage companies issued administrative punishment decisions: According to Article 37 of the Measures for the Administration of Public Rental Housing and Article 37 of the Measures for the Management of Real Estate Brokers, Zhongtian Real Estate and I Love My family imposed a fine of 60,000 yuan each, and recorded it in the credit file, suspending the two intermediary companies to sign online in Chaoyang District.

...The Beijing Municipal Construction and Construction Committee said that all districts have been required to immediately conduct global work investigations and implement local territorial supervision responsibilities. First, the property rights unit should earnestly implement the main responsibility and improve the daily inspection system in accordance with the principle of “who holds and who manages”. The second is to strengthen the urban linkage, through the establishment of family files and household visits, the combination of daily inspections and special inspections, and resolutely deal with the illegal violations, showing the government's "zero tolerance" attitude and determination. The third is to comprehensively promote the application of face recognition technology, use scientific and technological means to strengthen dynamic supervision, and deter violations.

Chinese Credit Growth Slows in August

M2 growth slowed to 8.2 percent. THe 3-month growth rate hit 10.8 percent, below the year-ago 11.1 percent.

Reuters: China Aug new loans fall as cooling economy makes both banks, borrowers wary
Chinese banks made fewer new loans in August than expected, highlighting problems facing the central bank as it tries to boost credit to smaller companies facing weaker demand at home and shrinking export orders.
M2 growth offset depreciation in August. Reserves accounted for 11.88 percent of M2 supply, down from 11.94 percent a month earlier. The low was 11.36 percent in March 2018.

Civil War in the Catholic Church

The Western civil war is in the Catholic Church, following belatedly on the heels of Protestant denominations.

USA Today: 'Civil war' divides world's Catholics amid allegations of sex abuse, coverup
Dozens of commentators and Vatican watchers have pointed to the wide gap between the views of conservative, traditional Catholics in the mold of Pope Benedict XVI, Francis’ predecessor, and those of reform-minded Catholics like Pope Francis. Many media have referred to what is happening as a kind of “civil war.”

Though he is widely popular among non-Catholics, Francis has been a polarizing figure among the faithful since he was first elected five years ago.

The latest sex abuse allegations, specifically those raised by Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, former nuncio to the United States, have only increased public pressure on Francis to resign in order to save the church.
A civil war in the Church reflects negative mood, but it isn't much of a war over the long-term. Protestant denominations that modernize cease to exist within a generation or two. To use a business example, churches that modernize are chasing their least loyal customers and turn off their most loyal customers. If the reformers win, the Catholic Church will collapse and the traditionalists will remain and take over. If the traditionalists win, the Church will shrink, but not as much as it would have. Either way, the future is with the traditionalists.

More broadly, the "civil war" mirrors the #MeToo movement in Hollywood. Secular institutions (Church modernists who seek accommodation with the world) that seized moral authority are revealed to be the most immoral actors. "The louder he spoke of his honor, the faster we counted our spoons."

2018-09-12

Next Up, European Civil War

Eastern Europe, including East Germany, are on a different political trajectory from Western Europe. The West is turning nationalist on migration, but the East has a full program. Today's move by the, Putin puppets in Europe?, makes a formal break by censuring Hungary for being against "European values."

ZH: Hungary's Orban Slapped With Unprecedented EU Censure Over Claims Of "Authoritarian Rule"
On Wednesday members of European Parliament voted on the move as a result of what EU lawmakers say is a breach of the European bloc's values and laws and eroding democratic standards, and amidst accusations Hungary is now an "autocracy". The rebuke was passed by 448 votes to 197.

Meanwhile Orban bit back ahead of the EU censure vote, saying before Parliament the planned move “insults the honor of the Hungarian nation” and was “a slap in the face”; and the controversial prime minister further cast the whole charade is an attempt to "blackmail" Hungary into bowing to EU pressures to soften its hard line stance on the migrant issue.
For those who want to understand where Orban comes from and his political goals, and have only heard the mainstream description of him as an autocrat, this book is worth checking out: The Second Term of Viktor Orbán: Beyond Prejudice and Enthusiasm

From the outside, it looks like Orban destroyed communist influence in his country. Much of his policies were designed to eradicate communist influences. Many communists stayed on in government and various government institutions. Orban removed them.

The socialist-leaning mainstream in Europe is rightly shocked at how effective he's been at wiping them out and leaving very little trace. Their power base is in state media, courts and schools, and once flushed out, the Eastern European public does not want many leftist policies. If they can manufacture consent and control the terms of debate they can win because it creates a false choice, but in a free-for-all, they lose. Hence in the United States, the censorship on social media. They do not want a level playing field where all ideas compete. Those who scream loudest about democracy are often the most undemocratic of all.

American Soybeans Turning Chinese Boys Into Sissies

Xinhua blasts the girly-boy trend in culture and entertainment. South Korea started the trend, so blame them.

Androgyny was big in the 1970s and 1930s, periods of negative social mood. Extremely negative social mood, such as Germany in the 1920s, saw the rise of transgenderism. The Socionomic signals point to negative and declining social mood.

From an evolutionary perspective, perhaps this is a response to overpopulation. Or the debunked studies that linked low testosterone with heavy soy consumption, which developed into the soy boy meme.

Perhaps China can make use of the soy boy meme. With U.S. soybean exports in the crosshairs of the trade war and shots fired in the culture war, China can kill two birds with one stone and blame American soybeans.

Xinhua: 辛识平:“娘炮”之风当休矣
To be a cultural person, and to educate people. The reason why the "sissies" phenomenon caused public resentment is also because the negative impact of this morbid culture on young people cannot be underestimated. Adolescents are the future of the country. Although the criticism of the "juvenile mothers and mothers" on the Internet is not without jokes, what a social and national pop culture embraces, rejects, and disseminates is indeed a major event in the future of the country. To cultivate new people in the era of national rejuvenation, we need to resist the erosion of bad culture and the nourishment of excellent culture.

Scholar Neil Bozeman once warned people in his book "Entertainment to Death": What ruined us is not what we hate, but what we "love". In the face of dazzling various "pan-entertainment" phenomena, it is necessary and valuable to revisit and think about this rational voice.

Stop Blaming Slowing Chinese Economy on Trade War, Or Get Shutdown

There have been some bearish posts in the past couple of months such as Cat Sister Sees More Yuan Depreciation. If China is cracking down on financial media, these articles will dry up.

I suspect the first source in the article is correct. The trade war is too political. Decisions about it go straight to the top. Mistakes are blamed on the leadership. Moreover, many around the world are incorrectly blaming Chinese economic weakness, yuan depreciation and falling A-shares on the trade war. They are ascribing political blame where it does not belong.

The truth will be revealed by the performance of Chinese assets and related articles. If the government is censoring heavily, there will be more "buy the dip" and "leaders are working hard" propaganda. If the censors are targeting political articles, there will still be plenty of "dollar shortage," "Federal Reserve did it," "pledged stock loans," "struggling SMEs," along with bearish forecasts.

SCMP: China financial news service shuts down, ‘sorry’ for unspecified mistakes
A source from another mainland internet portal, which receives instructions from Chinese censors, said the harsh punishment over NetEase’s financial and economic news coverage may be linked to an ongoing campaign by Beijing to stabilise confidence in China’s economic prospects amid an escalating trade war with the United States.

“Trade war is the likely reason,” said the source, who declined to be named. “We’ve received warnings about trade war coverage.”

China has previously told its journalists to play down negative impact of the US-China trade war and banned them from linking the trade war with financial market turmoil, from stock market declines to depreciation in the value of the yuan.

Government officials and state media outlets are sending a consistent message that China can successfully manage any fallout from the trade war. China’s top leadership has listed “stabilising expectations” as a key priority in its management of the economy.

In the latest meeting of the Financial Stability and Development Committee, the agency coordinating financial regulation chaired by Vice-Premier Liu He, China’s top financial officials pledged to ensure stability in stocks, bonds and foreign exchange markets, and to avoid any “black swan” disruptions.

NetEase had been pulling analysis and views from social media platforms in its financial news, with many articles detailing the possible harm China could suffer from the trade war.

...A third source, who is close to China’s cyberspace administration, said NetEase was punished because it organised a big economics conference but did not let the censors know beforehand.

2018-09-11

Rising Social Insurance Collections Will Lower Rates, But What About the Evaders

Social security reform has been a hot topic of late. Prior coverage can be seen in these posts:

Social Security Change Could Cause Layoffs and Shave 1.5pc Off GDP in 2019
Chinese SMEs Can Only Survive Through Tax Evasion, Social Security Reform Could Be Killer
State Council Heard the Lamentations of the SMEs, Li Keqiang Call for More Cuts to Taxes, Fees

I'm leaning back towards thinking a policy error could be coming in 2019. One of the consistent themes in recent articles is that rates will come down when more people pay taxes. However, tax evasion is widespread and reports say it is concentrated in SMEs. These firms and their employees (co-conspirators in underpaying social insurance) will bear the brunt of compliance. Large and state-owned firms that already comply with the law will derive the largest benefit from rising compliance.

An example from Jiangmen, Guangdong is given in the article. Its tax bureau began collecting taxes more than a decade ago. Compliance and revenues grew steadily, the tax rate fell. This is the correct long-term forecast, but the question is how does it impact 2019? Reports say many businesses, perhaps around one-third, are making only minimum payments. Employees could be earning as much as 300 percent of the average and only paying taxes on 60 percent of the average salary. In 2019, their wages will stagnate or fall.

iFeng: 社保转税进展:五部门联合推动 为降费率争取更大空间
After the social insurance premiums are uniformly collected by the tax authorities, will there be a substantial increase in the burden of payment? This is also a question that everyone is very concerned about.

According to the requirements of social security contributions, the salary income of the previous year is generally the base of payment. If the wages and salaries of employees are higher than 300% of the average salary employees in the previous year, 300% of the average salary of the local employees in the previous year shall be the base of payment; if the wages of employees are lower than the average salary of 60% of the employees in the previous year, the previous year 60% of the average wage of employees is the base of payment; if the wages of employees are between 300% and 60%, they shall be declared according to the actual situation.

The "Daily Economic News" reporter noted that the vast majority of people belong to the base of payment according to the wages, but the actual situation is that some enterprises have significantly reduced the base payment.

According to Hu Yijian, a professor at Shanghai University of Finance and Economics, “According to the report on social security in 2018, less than 30% of companies pay in strict accordance with the social security system.”

At present, among the 36 provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the Central Government and cities with separate plans, 22 provinces and municipalities have been charged social security fees by the tax authorities.

Generally speaking, in the areas where the tax authorities collect social insurance premiums, the fee base is being implemented year by year, the rates are stable and the income is stable, and the income is growing steadily. For example, in Jiangmen City, Guangdong Province, since the taxation department unified the collection of basic old-age insurance premiums since 2005, efforts have been made to make the actual payment base, promote the expansion of insurance coverage, and the income has grown steadily. From 2005 to 2017, the number of households paying for old-age insurance premiums in the city increased by 8.6% annually, the average annual increase of contributions was 7.2%, the average per capita contribution base increased by 14%, and the average annual growth rate of social insurance premiums was 17.8%. At the same time, the city's rate was gradually reduced from 17% before the transfer to 13%.

The aforementioned people close to the State Administration of Taxation analyzed to reporters that after the tax authorities were responsible for collecting social insurance premiums, the capacity of collection and management would indeed increase, which has already formed a consensus in society. It is necessary to levy the expenses that have not been collected before, so as to gain more space for the overall reduction of the rate. From this point of view, for enterprises that pay according to law, the tax levy will gradually and reasonably decline, creating a more fair environment for the majority of enterprises.

Beijing Finance Bureau Demands 89 Documents from P2P Platforms, 1 False Equals Shutdown

P2P platforms will go through a thorough investigation in Beijing and if 1 piece of documentary evidence is false or lie by omission, the platform will lose its license to operate.

21st Century: 北京金融局要求P2P再交89项材料 内容不真实即“一票否决”
The list of materials in the supplementary notice shows that the information submitted by the online lending institution needs to include the company's basic information, the company's system documents and relevant supporting materials, the contract text and relevant supporting materials, financial information and related data statistics, depository banks, information disclosure, There are 89 items in 9 categories, such as information security, description documents, and other materials.

The 21st Century Business Herald noted that some materials are very detailed. For example, shareholders, actual controllers, Dong Jiangao and their close relatives who hold more than 5% of the shares of online lending institutions need statistics and provide ID numbers. Mobile phone number and other information. Among the employee statistics, even the interns are required to report.

A person close to the supervision said that the "108" issued in the previous notice is a list of P2P online lenders' compliance inspection questions, which are included in the self-inspection report and should be submitted before September 30, no later than no later than October 15, 2018. The list of 89 documents in the Supplemental Notice is used as a supplementary document or evidence for Article 108 and must be submitted by October 15.

If the material is not true, it will be "one vote veto"

On August 24 this year, the Beijing Municipal Financial Bureau issued the "Notice on Launching the Self-examination of P2P Network Lending Institutions Registered in Beijing" to launch a new round of self-examination of P2P. The notice requires that the P2P registered in Beijing will be notified by the Beijing Mutual Rehabilitation Office of the “Resolution Notice for the Facilitation of Internet Loan Information Intermediary Agency”, which was established before August 24, 2016 and engaged in online lending business, still in normal operation. The institutions need to carry out self-examination, and submit self-examination reports, authenticity commitments, and benign exit plans after rectification failures to the rectification office.

On September 7, the Beijing Municipal Financial Bureau again requested the online lending institutions to submit 89 self-discipline inspection and administrative verification materials before October 15, 2018, in accordance with the above-mentioned Notice.

A person familiar with the matter told the 21st Century Business Herald that there were more than 400 P2P institutions that had been inspected and issued a rectification notice by the Beijing Financial Bureau. They were all connected to the “Golden Management” system on a monthly basis. Report the operation and the overall improvement exhibition.

According to the above-mentioned person close to the supervision, the 89 materials required to be submitted are the focus of the self-discipline inspection of the Mujin Association and the administrative inspection of the Financial Bureau. The administrative inspection pays special attention to the authenticity of the materials. If the content is found to be untrue, deliberately mislead, omissions, fraud, etc., the "one-vote veto system" is implemented.
The story goes on to say that regulatory compliance will be easier for smaller platforms with smaller volume and limited scope of operations.

Liu He Oversees 4 State Council Finance Committee Meetings in 2 Months

iFeng: 刘鹤主持,70天开了4次!国务院金融委会议释放哪些信号
Maintaining a stable and healthy development of stock bonds

The third meeting of the Finance Committee believed that the current macroeconomic situation was generally stable, economic and financial maintained a stable development trend, supply-side structural reforms continued to deepen, employment remained stable, and micro-subject resilience was further enhanced.

Preventing and mitigating major risks is the primary task of winning the three major battles to build a well-off society, and financial risks are the top priority. The meeting pointed out that the implementation of a prudent and neutral monetary policy was actively implemented, and in accordance with the changes in the situation, targeted and appropriate pre-adjustment and fine-tuning were carried out in a timely and appropriate manner, "but we must also grasp the degree of goodness."

In response to the recent fluctuations in the stock market, bond market and foreign exchange market, the meeting has specifically stated that it will continue to effectively resolve various financial risks, not only to prevent the stock risks, but also to prevent various "black swan" incidents, and to maintain the stock market, bond market and foreign exchange market. Smooth and healthy development.

At the same time, the meeting emphasized strengthening the cooperation between the departments, especially strengthening the coordination of the financial sector with the finance and development and reform departments, increasing the precision of policy support, and better promoting the development of the real economy.

In addition, capital market reform, property rights and intellectual property protection, and the effectiveness of incentive mechanisms were also arranged at the meeting.
Four meetings in 70 days

The four sessions of the new Finance Committee up to now, including three regular meetings including the third meeting, and one special meeting, were presided over by Liu He, Vice Premier of the State Council and Director of the Financial Committee.

On July 2nd, the first meeting of the new Finance Committee was held on the same day. The meeting held that the current Chinese economy is moving towards high-quality development, and the market entity has strong resilience. The large-scale market in China has a wide swing space and is fully capable of winning. There are many favorable conditions for major risks and major risks, and we are full of confidence. The next steps will be carried out in an orderly manner according to the established plan.

The meeting also decided to hold regular plenary meetings and hold targeted conferences from time to time to coordinate research and coordination of matters related to the financial sector.

Huang Yiping, deputy dean of the National Development Research Institute of Peking University, believes that this meeting is the next stage of action to prevent and resolve financial risks.

At the beginning of August, the Finance Committee held its second meeting to clarify that the overall financial situation is improving. It is required to deal with the relationship between stable growth and risk prevention, macro-capital and micro-credit, play an active role in fiscal policy, and deepen financial reform. It is to study to further unblock the policy transmission mechanism and enhance the ability of serving the real economy.

Li Yimin, a macro analyst at Shenwan Hongyuan, pointed out that this meeting continued the spirit of the 731 Politburo meeting and continued to provide more environmental premise and hedging on the basis of firm de-leverage to ensure supply-side reform in the second half of the year. The economy is moving smoothly and simultaneously. The policy mix of “stable and wide” of stable currency, strict supervision and wide credit has been clarified and will be implemented more; the policy focuses on precise design, and the leverage will be more stable, which means that the policy will be more moderate in the second half of the year. However, the policy marginal easing is not a big release, and it is in line with the logic of deepening reform in the transition phase, and helps stabilize the market's expectations of the policy.

On August 24th, more than 20 days later, the Financial Committee held a special conference on preventing and defusing financial risks, listening to the progress of the special rectification work of the network lending industry and preventing the resolution of the stock pledge risks of listed companies, and demanding that the online loan risk should be handled. Emphasis is placed on preventing and defusing the risk of stock pledge of listed companies and deepening capital market reform.

This is the first special conference held since the establishment of the new Finance Committee, and it is also the first time that the new Finance Committee meeting focused on the capital market.

Regarding the risk of online loans, any Haifeng of the Center for Financial Policy Research of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences said in an interview with the media that the next step should be to carry out further precise classification management for different situations in different regions. The ultimate goal is to return the online loan to the essence of the information platform. In this way, the risk of excessive involvement in financial activities, financial products, etc., without prior qualifications, can be separated.

Talking about the stock pledge of listed companies, Dong Dengxin, director of the Institute of Financial Securities of Wuhan University of Science and Technology, said that equity pledge is a popular loan method in recent years, and the risk may occur in the future. Therefore, the special meeting proposed to strengthen the reform of the capital market, increase marketization and legalization, and (help) provide a relatively transparent and predictable market environment for stock pledge.

Beijing Raids Real Estate Broker 我爱我家?

The Beijinger: Fake Online Apartment Rental Listings Proliferate Despite Government Crackdown
Despite government instructions to remove misleading listings, online housing rental platforms including 58.com (58同城), Anjuke (安居客), and Fang.com (房天下) have failed to abide by the order.

An investigation by the Beijing News found that after the Beijing Municipal Housing and Urban-Rural Development Committee, among others, issued a deadline of Sep 1 to clean up these listings, the companies still had not complied with the directive.

...Once prospective renters have been attracted by low prices and striking apartments, agents take them to view numerous properties within in the same price range, often with none of them matching the pictures in the listing.
There are headlines claiming 我爱我家 (5i5j.com) was raided by Beijing police. A number of headlines say this, but are now 404 or redirected back to homepages. A new story says 我爱我家 was investigated along with other brokers, but it was a normal regulatory check-up.

Here's the headline that is 404'd. I couldn't find the original article anywhere. The headline said the Beijing govt raided 我爱我家, employee phones and computers investigated.

iFeng: 北京市发改委昨日突袭我爱我家 员工电脑当场被查验 another version: 北京市发改委昨日突袭我爱我家 员工手机电脑当场被查验.

This is the replacement article.

iFeng: 我爱我家否认涉嫌垄断操纵租金 称“行业例行交流常态”
September 11 news against the media said that the Beijing Municipal Development and Reform Commission on 5i5j suspected of using monopoly to manipulate the rent investigation, September 11, 5i5j official statement, the relevant news is not true. 5i5j said that the relevant government departments have recently visited and investigated a number of leasing operators, which is the normal state of routine exchanges in the industry.

In the morning, the Beijing Municipal Development and Reform Commission yesterday conducted an investigation into the Beijing company on the fact that 5i5j used the monopoly to manipulate rents. An insider from 5i5j revealed that the personal computers and mobile phones of the three or four key employees of the Beijing company were investigated on the spot.

Related: China’s 58.com Acquires $164M Stake In Rental Brokerage Company 5I5J

Alibaba and Ethereum

I made note of this in the recent post on cryptos, but here's Alibaba and Ethereum on the same chart.

2018-09-10

Govt Sues Company for Back Social Security, Owner Eats Instant Noodles

Another Chinese consumer is upgrading to the convenience of instant noodles. He happens to be famous because his Changzhou, Jiangsu glass factory was sued for 10 years of back social security. Now it is closed.

iFeng: 独家调查:常州工厂被追缴十年社保背后
Li Liangda, the boss of Changzhou Yuhua Glass Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Yuhua Glass"), did not expect that he would be famous for not paying social security.

On August 23, the People's Court of Xinbei District, Changzhou City, Jiangsu Province issued an administrative ruling showing that Changzhou Yuhua Glass Co., Ltd. owed basic pension insurance premium, basic medical insurance premium, and work injury insurance from December 2007 to November 2017. Fees, unemployment insurance premiums, and maternity insurance premiums totaled 2,011,134.15 yuan. The Fifth Taxation Bureau of the Changzhou Local Taxation Bureau of Jiangsu Province made a decision on the collection of social insurance premiums and imposed social insurance premiums on Yuhua Glass. After the levy decision takes effect, the tax authorities apply to the court for enforcement because the company has not fulfilled its payment obligations.
There's roughly 2 trillion in back payments across the Chinese economy.
On July 20, 2018, the China Office and the State Council issued the “Regulations on the Reform of the Taxation and Administration System of National Taxes and Local Taxes”. The "Proposal" stipulates that from January 1, 2019, all social security payments will be levied by the tax authorities. Prior to this, the tax department levied a tax, and the human and social departments collected social insurance premiums, leaving an “operating space” for enterprises to pay less wages. According to estimates by Guotai Junan, after the social security reform is levied by the tax bureau, enterprises and individuals will pay a total of nearly 2 trillion yuan.
As covered recently in Social Security Change Could Cause Layoffs and Shave 1.5pc Off GDP in 2019, and Chinese SMEs Can Only Survive Through Tax Evasion, Social Security Reform Could Be Killer and State Council Heard the Lamentations of the SMEs, Li Keqiang Call for More Cuts to Taxes, Fees, SMEs greatly fear the impact of the law. They fear they could end up like Yuhua Glass.
When the Changzhou court verdict came out, it caused a huge response. Many voices believe that the recovery of Changzhou Local Taxation Bureau has a symbolic significance, which means that local tax bureaus will recover social security from enterprises, given small and micro enterprises barely survive today, it is likely they will die.
Li Liangda did not particularly care about the impact on himself, he is more concerned about the future of his factory. Since the factory was shut down at the end of June, more than 100 workers in Yuhua Glass have left the factory to find, at present, there is almost only one person in Li Liangda, and the canteen chef is no longer coming to work. Li Liangda bought a few crates of instant noodles to allay his hunger.

For Yuhua Glass, Li Liangda said that he has deep feelings and has been working in this factory since he was founded in 1975. He has been working for more than 40 years.

For the future, Li Liang said that if the government can take over Yuhua Glass, he will wash his hands and retire,
but he still hopes that Yuhua Glass will be able to reopen and pay the workers' social security.

...Li Liangda said that Yuhua’s glass debt has reached 30 million, but the assets are 30-40 million yuan, and the assets can still be repaid.

For the future, Li Liangda is quite confused and looks forward to regaining production through rectification and thus getting out of trouble. If production cannot be resumed, it is hoped that the local government will take over and he can retire.
The article gives an in-depth history of the factory, from state-ownership to the privatization 10 years ago, to recent troubles as customers in the pharmaceutical industry switch to plastic bottles.
"This factory is inseparable from people. Although it is not producing, the inventory still needs to be sold, and some of the accounts need to be recovered. I can only stare at it every day." In the Yuhua Glass Factory, after Li Liangda learned this reporter also hadn't eaten, invited me to eat instant noodles together.

A Real Bear Market: A-Shares Sink Following Ministry and Media Support

Nothing will stop the A-shares bear market except a shift in sentiment. Last month was terrible for securities firms: Chinese Brokers Profits Fall to 10pc of Bull Market Peak. Over the past few days, the government launched another policy and propaganda blitz (after the one in mid-August had little impact) and there were headlines saying the bottoming process is underway. Stocks moved lower on Monday. New headlines warn the bottoming process can involve a breakdown to new lows.

iFeng: 沪指跌超1% 深成指、创业板指齐创调整以来新低
Specific closing point: Shanghai Composite Index closed at 2669.48 points, down 1.21%, turnover was 102.9 billion; Shenzhen Component Index closed at 8158.49 points, down 1.97%, turnover was 145 billion; GEM closed at 1390.82 points, down 2.41%, with a turnover of 45.8 billion.

In terms of the industry sector, except for the slight increase in gas water, the rest of the sector floated green. Computers, securities, e-commerce and other sectors were among the top losers, with both falling more than 3%.

More than 3,000 stocks fell in the two markets, and 27 stocks were limit down.
The failure to bounce on Monday has swung the headlines from cautious optimism to warning of a breakdown.

iFeng: 你在考虑抄底?请注意!后市行情大概率向下突破
Today, the key words of A-shares are new lows. The Shenzhen Stock Index hit a new low since December 2014. The GEM is a four-year low. The Shanghai index is slightly better. There are still more than a dozen points away from 2653, but the probability of breakdown in the market is also Larger.

After the A-share fell into this bear-like sample, can it now be copied?

First ask, is it the bottom now? What is the nature of the bottom?

The master of the resurrection believes that there is still a distance between the stocks at the bottom of the medium and long-term. In the short-term, there will be a partial rebound after each decline, but they are all relatively short-lived. In the case of individual stocks, some follow the market trend and are wrongly killed. The blue chip stocks can look at the opportunities.
Nevertheless, it may be a good time to buy if you can hold.
Second, ask, what kind of risk appetite are you?

If your money is not easy to earn, and you have to be responsible for eating and drinking, then don't enter the market now; if you are already in the middle class, and you are willing to contribute to the A-shares, then now, the master will never Stop; if you are rich and rich, then you may wish to carry forward some spirit, buy some stocks, long-term, do not believe that you can not make money in the next year!

According to institutional statistics, investors only need to subscribe to the fund below 2800 points to make a profit. The average yield of holding one year is 41.03%, the average yield of holding three years is 102.37%, and the average yield of holding five years is as high as 146.91%.

But buying stocks should not be so lucky.

All in all, A shares are now in the bottoming stage, blindly smashing the bottom and being shot dead on the beach. The source of the organization directly stated that the market transformation needs to be able to support the breakthrough, and the market outlook will break through.
If you can't afford to buy A-shares at bargain basement pricing, maybe you should be eating instant noodles.