2016-01-18

Industrial Production Grows 5.9% in December

Industrial production looked stable from the headline number, but there was some deterioration in the details. Electricity production was its lowest since March, a decline of 3.7% yoy. Electric generator production plunged 29.8% yoy in December, well ahead of the 13.8% decline for all of 2015. December coke, plate glass, iron and steel production were also down sharply from the full year growth rate.
Steel

Cement

Autos

Electricity

NBS: 2015年12月份规模以上工业增加值增长5.9%

Fixed Asset Investment Grows 6.8% in December

Fixed asset investment grew 6.8% in December, closing out the year with a 10.0% percent increase. IF the trend at the end of 2015 carries into 2016, look for growth to start the year at an approximately 8% pace.
Private fixed asset investment was stronger, rising 8.5% in December, and closing out the year with a 10.1% increase. The fastest single month yoy growth was 14.7% in Jan-Feb, and the slowest was 6.7% in September.
NBS: 2015年全国固定资产投资(不含农户)增长10%
2015年民间固定资产投资增长10.1%

Real Estate Investment Negative for 5th Straight Month in December

Real estate investment growth closed the year with a 1% year on year gain, but it finished the year with 5 consecutive year-on-year monthly contractions, finishing with a 1.9% contraction in December.
Analysts are looking for the real estate recovery to run out of steam in the summer. As this sales chart shows (yellow is area, blue yuan) the year-on-year comparisons have it easy until June.

NBS: 2015年全国房地产开发投资和销售情况

Chinese Meritocracy vs Western Democracy

The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy, Reviewed by Tongdong Bai, Fudan University
The second model is a hybrid of democracy and meritocracy, which can be implemented by a bicameral structure with a house of "meritocrats," a model Bell himself championed before. He discusses the proposals made by Sun Yat-sen, Friedrich Hayek, and Jiang Qing, as well as the English House of Lords, and argues that the meritocratic house will be overshadowed by the democratically elected house when people enjoy a sense of empowerment through one-person-one-vote. East Asian societies cannot bet on the meritocratic heritage because Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan have all embraced electoral democracy instead of a Confucian hybrid regime.

The third model is democracy on the bottom, and meritocracy on top (through selections that are discussed in Chapter 2). In the Concluding Remarks, Bell also adds a middle level that allows experiments in combining meritocracy and democracy. He calls this three-level structure the China model. But in order for meritocracy on top to work, the potential candidates, when going through a long period of training, need guarantees that their training will be rewarded. This means that one-party rule is a pre-condition. Then, the problem of the legitimacy of such a meritocracy can only be ultimately solved by a referendum that can render legitimacy to this regime for a long period of time (say, 50 years) until the next referendum.
On the "closing of the Western mind" Bai writes:
But this book has also been ruthlessly savaged by (some) critics with similar accusations. Many of these critics sound like ideologues. Their belief in the alleged open society of liberal democracy is closed to open discussions. To them, anyone who dares to challenge the desirability of liberal democracy must be either foolish or evil. They owe us an explanation about why the West has been failing in so many fronts, and China has been doing relatively well. Moreover, Bell is not painting a purely rosy picture of China, and he offers critical remarks on the Chinese regime. Nonetheless, I feel that Bell gives too much credit to the present Chinese regime and not enough to criticisms of it. While criticizing the end-of-history view about liberal democracy, he himself seems to think that China will continue to be successful under the present Chinese regime, with its present way of doing politics. I am not that optimistic.

I share with Bell many of his criticisms of contemporary liberal democracy and many of his normative proposals. But some of his ideas seem somewhat one-sided. For example, he argues that to have one-party-rule is essential to meritocratic selection, but I think the key is really that when one's party is not in power, the meritocrat-in-training can find meaningful employment, which presupposes different channels for the politically talented and their mobility in society -- something American society does offer and the Chinese authority has been calling for recently.

The Game Is Afoot: PBoC Raises Knife At Speculators

Reuters: China’s yuan firms as central bank keeps pressure on speculators
China’s yuan rose on Monday as the central bank announced a fresh move to deter offshore speculation in the currency, while stocks rebounded modestly from near levels last seen at the depths of last year’s summer crash.

The People’s Bank of China (PBOC) said it would start implementing a reserve requirement ratio (RRR) on offshore banks’ domestic deposits, in a move that seemed intended to soak up additional liquidity.

“The market sees that this is a gesture by the PBOC to warn speculators that are betting on a fast depreciation of its currency,” said Zhou Hao, senior emerging markets economist for Asia at Commerzbank AG in Singapore.
Nothing like soaking up liquidity amid a massive wave of deflation.

Barron's: PBoC Tightens Screws on Yuan Speculators
iFeng: 外媒:人民币保卫战升级?中国央行对国际空头举屠刀

The PBoC is dealing with symptoms. The futures market hasn't really budged despite the latest moves by the PBoC and the drop in CNH in recent days. Long-term yuan bears are betting these moves will have temporary impact because the fundamentals are moving against the central bank. Furthermore, recall posts from yesterday: Chinese Dollars Have Stopped Flowing and Banks Ponder Unwinding of Hundreds of Billions in Currency Arbitrage. Are speculators the target, or is the PBoC tightening the noose around Chinese borrowers? If you are an "accidental" currency speculator (believing the yuan would always rise or remain stable, and thus seeing your massive USD loans and RMB WMP investments as near risk-free interest rate arbitrage instead of a high risk currency+interest rate arbitrage) the torschlusspanik must be close to setting in if it hasn't already.

As for the deeper fundamentals.
Bloomberg: China's Hot Bond Market Seen at Risk of Default Chain Reaction
Credit derivatives that are seen as a gauge of risk in the market have spiked 22 basis points since Dec. 31, the worst start to a year in data going back to 2008. The number of listed firms with debt double equity has jumped to 339 amid a weakening economy, from 185 in 2007. Traders surveyed by Bloomberg in December said note failures will spread.

“2016 is a year when we will see systemic risks emerge in China’s credit market,” said Ji Weijie, credit analyst in Beijing at China Securities Co., the top arranger of bond offerings from state-owned and listed firms. "There may be a chain reaction as more companies are likely to fail in a slowing economy and related firms could go down too."
Bloomberg: China Hits a Bump, or Two, on Road to an Internationalized Yuan
China is caught in a dilemma as it pushes toward eventually letting market forces determine the yuan’s value, but in the short term clings to old government controls to defend the currency and prevent a capital outflow that could harm stability and dent economic growth. What’s not clear is how the heavy-handed state measures will go over in the 20-odd yuan trading hubs that now stretch from Singapore to London to Toronto.

"In the past, the offshore market could work by itself to reflect market opportunities, but now it’s a currency controlled by the PBOC," said Iris Pang, a senior economist for Greater China at Natixis SA in Hong Kong. "Progress is stepping backward."
CNH has been structurally weakened for a temporary short-term strengthening in the exchange rate.

Taiwan is looking ahead: Taiwan asks banks to set reserves for possible yuan derivatives default
Taiwan's Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) will require banks to set aside reserves for possible default of a yuan derivative product amid sharp falls of the Chinese currency, three sources close to the regulator said on Monday.

The FSC also will ask investors to put down a 2 percent deposit for buying such products, which are called target redemption forwards (TRF), said the sources, who asked not to be identified as the matter is yet to be made public.

2016-01-17

Dollar Loan Prepayment May Be Fueling Reserve Drawdown

As part of an article on corporate USD debt, the EO says the prepayment of dollar debts could have fueled recent outflows:
Although only the case, but in the context of the RMB exchange rate stall, the market is reading a different kind of meaning. Dollar debt prepayment tide coming? Actually, this is one of the main reasons for the recent Chinese foreign exchange reserves shrink. "Prepayment indeed a great relationship with the exchange rate, if the dollar continues strong, the yuan continues to face pressure, this action needs to be done ahead of time, this year there are a large number can be paid in advance, appears the most in the real estate business," the North said a broker underwriting, abandon the dollar debt financing, and the election in the country to issue bonds, housing prices have become common practice ideas.
Explaining the rise of dollar borrowing:
Once upon a time, the continuous appreciation of the yuan against the US dollar to the Chinese enterprises to go abroad to finance a great opportunity to continue the devaluation of the dollar may even allow enterprises sitting on a low-cost financing opportunities, this situation attracts many Chinese companies into offshore the bond market.

Enter 2014, the amount of domestic enterprises to issue dollar bonds soared, according to data provided by Dealogic, in 2014, China offshore bond issuance amounted to 139.7 billion US dollars, of which, $ 104.7 billion of dollar-denominated bonds, accounting for 74.9%. And this force in enterprise bonds, not only in the domestic market financing more difficult real estate companies, including many Chinese business community, "leading backbone" China Metallurgical Group, Baosteel, the national grid and so have hundreds of millions of bonds scale. In 2015 dollar debt issuers among state-owned enterprises accounted for more than half.
EO: 人民币失速风口 中国企业美元债风险压顶

New Home Prices Rise in December

NBS confirms the CREIS report out earlier in the month. NBS says new home prices increased 0.20% mom, that matches the September figure. I've been tallying up the first-tier share of the price increase. Last month, the first-tier plus Xiamen were 55% of the national price increase, with Shenzhen nabbing 22% of the total national increase. In December, these numbers were 54% and 23%, almost no change (Shenzhen prices were up 3.2% mom). The national real estate market is recovering and first-tier is leading the way, but still no significant spread beyond the second tier. The biggest single drop was in Dandong, Liaoning down 0.9% mom in December.

Year over year, prices are up 0.24%.

Since 2010, average prices are up 9.1%.

March 2014: 4 cities saw declines in price mom, 10 cities were flat, 56 were up.
April: 8 cities saw declines in price mom, 18 cities were flat, 44 were up.
May: 35 cities saw declines in price mom, 20 cities were flat, 15 were up.
June: 55 cities saw declines in price mom, 7 cities were flat, 8 were up.
July: 64 cities saw declines in price mom, 4 cities were flat, 2 were up.
August: 68 cities saw declines in price mom, 1 city was flat, 1 was up.
September: 69 cities saw declines in price mom, 1 city was flat, 0 were up.
October: 69 cities saw declines in price mom, 1 city was flat, 0 were up.
November: 67 cities saw declines in price mom, 3 cities were flat, 0 were up.
December: 65 cities saw declines in price mom, 4 cities were flat, 1 was up.
January 2015: 65 cities saw declines in price mom, 3 cities were flat, 2 were up.
February: 66 cities saw declines in price mom, 2 cities were flat, 2 were up.
March: 49 cities saw declines in price mom, 9 cities were flat, 12 were up.
April: 47 cities saw declines in price mom, 5 cities were flat, 18 were up.
May: 41 cities saw declines in price mom, 9 cities were flat, 20 were up.
June: 34 cities saw declines in price mom, 9 cities were flat, 27 were up.
July: 39 cities saw declines in price mom, 10 cities were flat, 31 were up.
August: 26 cities saw declines in price mom, 9 cities were flat, 35 were up.
September: 21 cities saw declines in price mom, 10 cities were flat, 39 were up.
October: 33 cities saw declines in price mom, 10 cities were flat, 27 were up.
November: 27 cities saw declines in price mom, 10 cities were flat, 33 were up.
December: 26 cities saw declines in price mom, 5 cities were flat, 39 were up.

Existing home prices were up nearly the same amount as new home prices last month, rising 0.19% mom. The city up/down breakdown was the same as with new home prices. The first-tier plus Xiamen accounted for 62% of the increase in existing homes nationally.

Source: 2015年12月份70个大中城市住宅销售价格变动情况

Zombie Disposal Will Last Two to Three Years

January 15 to 16, held a meeting of heads of central enterprises over the previous few days later, as usual, the meetings are usually held in December last year. Stakeholders analysis, the meeting postponed largely because the central enterprise restructuring and personnel changes frequently.

The meeting identified seven tasks in 2016, is to enhance the quality and efficiency of state-owned enterprises are developing actively disposal "zombie companies" to deepen the reform of state-owned capital of their own country and to promote the reform of the SASAC, conduct public business, Peoples innovation, promote international business strengthen supervision to prevent the loss of state assets, as well as state-owned enterprises to strengthen party building.

China Enterprise Institute researcher Lee Kum "Daily Economic News" reporter, said: "This meeting passed out six new ideas: First, the next two to three years will be 'in the throes of the' state-owned enterprise reform and development;.......

...In the meeting of heads of central enterprises, SASAC director Zhang also admitted that reform and development will enter "labor pains."

Li Jin told reporters that the "labor pains" First comes from iron and steel , coal , petroleum, petrochemical and other industries in the presence of a large number of "zombie companies", and such enterprises get together and mainly state-owned enterprises, therefore, the SASAC, the clean up zombie enterprises heavier tasks.

...It is worth noting that the SAC for the first time to clean "zombie companies" provides a timetable. Zhang said the SASAC is studying the program of work, and strive to use about three years to basically complete the main task, to 2020, the full completion of the work.
Three methods for reorganizing the zombies are horizontal, vertical and "leading enterprises:"
Zhang stressed that the increasing levels of mergers and acquisitions group, pushing combination; promote specialization restructuring to industry leading enterprises rely on cooperation through equity, asset replacement, free transfer, etc., to further strengthen the integration and homogenization of business sub-industry consolidation.

At this meeting, the SAC highlight three recombinant modes, horizontal industrial restructuring, reorganization and longitudinal chains to leading enterprises as the center of the restructuring.
Three examples of these reorganization strategies:
"Daily Economic News" reporter combing found that , operating sugar, meat and other food production and processing, wholesale and retail of Guohong [0.00%] Fu Trade Development Group entirety COFCO, China Ocean [ -8.88% funding research report ] and China Shipping, China South Locomotive [ -4.31% funding research report ] and China CNR [0.00% funds research report ] of the merger and reorganization, can be regarded as a generally horizontal industrial restructuring.

Vertical industry restructuring as the main chain of integrated logistics and shipping of China's Sinotrans [ -1.96% ] CSC entirety Merchants Group. Main daily consumer goods trade, hotels tourism , real estate management and development and integrated logistics services Nanguang Group.

The same as the world's top 500 enterprises in restructuring China Minmetals China Metallurgical Group Corporation was merged into another Fortune 500 companies, it embodies the characteristics of the industry leading enterprise restructuring.
iFeng: 僵尸国企兼并重组三年完成 官方定三种模式

Reuters has English coverage: China to clean-up 'zombie' companies by 2020: Xinhua
China's top state-owned asset administrator has vowed to clean-up the country's so-called "zombie" industrial companies by 2020, the official Xinhua News Agency has reported.

Zhang Yi, Chairman of the State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission (SASAC), told a central and local enterprise work conference convened at the weekend that the agency will "basically" resolve the problem of unproductive "zombie" firms over the next three years.

Dealing with "zombie companies" is very difficult, Zhang said, according to the report, but "officials need to... use today's 'small tremors' to prevent a future earthquake."

Banks Ponder Unwinding of Hundreds of Billions in Currency Arbitrage

Banks are scrambling to find ways to lessen their risk to USD loans, a result of companies borrowing overseas in U.S. dollars and depositing money into domestic financial products.
21st Century Business Herald from Shanghai to more than bankers Department learned that due to the continued appreciation of the dollar since January, corporate dollar loans, including loan business within the warranty are affected. For export enterprises, because the high cost of long-term [USD] loans, currently less hedging instruments that can be used, each bank is actively studying response options.
A major risk is the hot money inflows created by companies who obtained U.S. dollar loans and invested in high yield RMB financial products:
According to its introduction, there are some companies to borrow dollars abroad, but held that the RMB assets, such as RMB financing products, or RMB investment projects, after the expiration sell RMB assets, into US dollars repayment. This is at a higher interest rate of RMB, US dollar interest rates low while the RMB exchange rate remained stable, and the rise of the situation, with arbitrage space. But in the devaluation of the RMB exchange rate and the volatility of the time, this formed the currency mismatch risk exposure.

"At present, more and more companies see to make adjustments. On the one hand, is to reduce the assets to RMB assets sold, or investment recovery, to return the dollar loans, so that the entire balance sheet of enterprises will decline, it should say is healthy. "The person said," Or, hard to deal with RMB assets in the short term, there is the dollar liabilities adjusted to RMB. "
One Chinese analyst estimates there's $700 billion looking to reverse this arbitrage trade.

It may already be too late for these speculators (who may still not think of themselves as speculators) because forward markets are already pricing in more devaluation. Additionally, as of October 2015, the margin requirement on long-term FX forwards is 20%.
According to "People's Bank of China on the long-term sale of foreign exchange to strengthen macro-prudential management notice", from October 15, 2015, to carry out long-term sales business of financial institutions (including financial companies) to be turned over to the foreign exchange risk reserves, reserve provisional rate of 20%.

"So, after this policy, we have a forward foreign exchange related to the structure of the product offer, we will deviate from the market price, for enterprises, long-term lock exchange or foreign exchange swaps now is not a good choice." There are joint-stock banks people familiar with the operations said.

In addition to the customer's foreign exchange funds, the bank also has a small part of their foreign exchange working capital.
Recent rules on foreign exchange, in addition to the bank's own needs, also make it difficult for banks to meet customer demands:
The aforementioned state accusing him who introduced the international business department, for the bank's own risk control, for any one currency, how many stay long or short exposure, are strictly controlled. Meanwhile, in terms of the funding line, long after there is an upper limit of foreign exchange settlement and sales control. This means that banks will not convert any of their own foreign exchange funds into RMB.
21st CBH: 银行:收紧美元负债,外汇衍生品工具缺乏

One of the reasons to expect some amount of chaos in the currency market was due to the long-term stability of the yuan. Recent volatility in the renminbi still pales in comparison to typical volatility between the yen, euro and U.S. dollar. Yet firms in those countries don't panic over every 5% fluctuation in the currency market because they aren't levered up, a direct result of that same volatility. A great amount of leverage built up in the Chinese financial system because arbitrage investors kept building up their pool of capital, confident in the stability of the yuan-dollar exchange rate. What took years to build will now rush to the exits as stability is replaced with volatility.

Chinese Dollars Have Stopped Flowing

ZH, via China Law Blog:"China Banks Seem To Be Doing Whatever They Can To Avoid Paying Anyone In Dollars"
1. Chinese investors that have secured all necessary approvals to invest in American companies are not being allowed to actually make that investment. I mentioned this to a China attorney friend who says he has been hearing the same thing. Never heard this one until this month.

2. Chinese citizens who are supposed to be allowed to send up to $50,000 a year out of China, pretty much no questions asked, are not getting that money sent. I feel like every realtor in the United States has called us on this one. The Wall Street Journal wrote on this yesterday. Never heard this one until this month.

5. Get this one: Money will not be sent to any company on a services transaction unless that company can show that it does not have any Chinese owners. The alleged purpose behind this “rule” is again to prevent the sort of transactions ordinarily used to illegally move money out of China. Never heard this one until this month.
What does this mean for U.S., Canadian and Australian real estate markets which have seen heavy buying by Chinese investors?

What do you think of the "value" of the renminbi under these conditions? More or less than the "exchange" rate?

2016-01-16

Yu Pingkang: GDP Growth to Slow to 6.5%

First a comment on high home prices:
From the perspective of a Mai Tanweng him to talk about the Chinese economy, he pointed out that including himself and the younger generation, 80,90, or even 70, in the case of house prices continue to rise, especially in the city center has reached a high level, Many young people may work for a lifetime career in general can not afford. Ten years ago to the United States, most regret is the time now to leave China more than a dozen years ago, not much to buy several houses, come back later I found a never afford. He became a real proletarian and staunch communist warrior.
He says without stimulus China's growth rate will slow to about 6.5%:
Now we see the data, the economy began to pick up in the fourth quarter, but the next year will decline in the first quarter will decline in the second quarter also fell, down to which extent is it, if the efforts to ensure growth does not rise again, will down 6.5%, if, as the 2008 fourth quarter, again a four trillion, demand had changed. Under the existing policy efforts if the delay to the third quarter of this year will short-term stabilization, and then look to the future, depending on whether the structural reforms can really go forward.
iFeng: 专家:2016中国经济增长率将降至6.5%左右

Growth Industry 2016: Zombie Disposal

China may have found the solution to elimination zombie companies: zombie disposal business.

There are some differences between China and the rest of the world though.
Economist Peter Coy defines zombie companies as those that have no way to continue to operate, but have not gone through bankruptcy, these enterprises use bank loans and government funding to survive.

However, this standard does not fully distinguish China zombie companies. As state-owned enterprise reform in the 1990s witnesses believe, zombies enterprise itself does not have a quantitative standard, it is difficult to make accurate statistics.

One popular model 1998 reform of state-owned enterprises is, rather than part of the restructuring of the overall restructuring. Joint impact of this reform model brought, although some high-quality assets will successfully spun off a new company was established, but the poor quality assets remain in the surviving companies. Moreover, the reform steps go, the faster the industries, regions and businesses, the existence of the greater proportion of enterprises. This part of the business, which is the predecessor of zombie companies.

The legacy of many decades of reform, now began to liquidate cancellation equally difficult. Zombie old body part business, the coexistence of the new body, old body to undertake a large number of bad debts and non-performing assets, and other social affairs and responsibilities, and continue to produce charges. In liquidation, cancellation, many debt, debt needed to resolve through litigation, longer disposal cycle, resulting in cancellation of the old body difficult.

The Economic Observer newspaper has learned that the number of local SOE zombie companies are more than at the national level, and there is no lack of zombie companies among listed companies. Downward pressure on the economy has made market-clearing urgent. This round of zombie companies to clean up not only to be eliminated excess capacity, and clear the clogging from the supply side, more importantly, from the mechanism on past irrational economic structure and economic policy to make clean-up, do not allow the zombie companies another opportunity to hibernate.
One popular reform model was to break the company in two, let the new company take good
assets and grow rapidly, while handling the disposal of the remaining bad assets. Where do the zombies come from?
Zombie companies appear not accidental. Years of research zombie enterprises SASAC research center Director Wang Jiang believes that zombies shell companies similar enterprises, except that a portion of the housing shell companies can also play a relevant role, but zombie companies are mostly state-owned enterprise groups attached to the body, and the Group the main industry is not associated with, resulting in the Group organizational system bloated and complicated.
The number of zombie companies in 1998 was 39.1% of SOEs. The number now could be larger:
By the end of 1997, the then state-owned enterprises, there are also a part of the hardship, the national state-owned and state-holding industrial enterprises and medium-sized loss-making enterprises had once reached 6599, a loss of 39.1%. Up to now, contains a number of inefficient assets invalid zombie companies, the number is not necessarily less than 18 years ago.

That year, three-year turnaround in order to deal with and solve 999.638 billion yuan of total liabilities, help account for the state-owned and state holding large and medium industrial enterprises of all liabilities of 28.8 percent of 6,599 large and medium state-owned and state-holding industrial enterprises tide over their difficulties, have invested at least 30 billion yuan.
Local provinces are starting to roll out zombie disposal policies:
Since opening in 2016, Gansu, Hunan, Heilongjiang and other places have home position, strict disposal zombie companies. Currently there are more than 110 households in Gansu Province enterprises are partially stopped, debt over 150 billion yuan. From 2016 onwards, Gansu will be disposed and closed down a number of "no competitiveness and profitability", "resource-inefficient financial transfusion in particular rely on bank loans to survive," more than "three years of continuous losses do not meet the structural adjustment direction "zombie companies.

Next, Gansu will dispose of zombie companies this year to resolve the overcapacity as "key point", by shutting down the reorganization, capacity to participate in international cooperation to accelerate the intensive development and other ways to resolve excess capacity and will support in taxation, non-performing assets, unemployment re-employment and livelihood security and other aspects of policy programs disposal.

The Hunan practice will stop subsidies and protection in 2016, to achieve market clearing. According to the national deployment, Hunan Commission by letter as soon as possible to all walks of life zombie companies to thoroughly investigate and timely treatment. 2016 will be out of more than 1000 companies overcapacity.
Pain may be felt in the stock market:
It is worth noting that the current zombie companies nationwide, there are many listed companies. CASS Institute of Economics researcher Yuan Gangming said that in the book, published out of the financial statements show business still has a huge book contacts, such as large purchases, as well as production volume reflects the raw materials, but no cash flow.

Yuan Gangming said: "When the individual large corporate financing is particularly high, but the statements of listed companies, a large amount of debt is not reflected, these state-owned companies are very heavy, rigid, state-owned enterprises also causing low stock prices, because there is not enough cash flow and profitability supported only by lending countries invested a lot of money to maintain, the result can only be more to maintain the zombies. "

"Some companies are their own problems generated by the problem of excess production capacity to push up to the macroeconomic situation, and finally by the government to support." It is because in the past the role of market mechanism to play not large enough a role, too much government intervention, the market can not lead to timely clearing, triggering various structural contradictions. For example, some did not benefit the 'zombie companies', some places have to give loans to their teeth, give subsidies. "Yuan Steel confessed.

He used the steel industry for example, the larger steel companies can not sell more debt, but because a lot of money upfront investment, so that enterprises can not easily drained.

Yuan Gangming believes that once weaned off blood to zombie companies, not only bank loans can not be recovered, there will be a chain reaction, a large number of workers were laid off, the relevant association chain chain enterprises, many small companies that rely on large companies to eat will also encounter difficulty. Over time, simply turn a blind eye and let it happen.
Many steel stocks (as one example) are still trading at least double what they were going for back in 2013, even after the crash. A year ago these stocks were up several hundred percent and "good buys," now the debate is how to totally shut them down without causing mass unemployment and knock-on damage to the economy.

EO: 寻踪僵尸企业

1998 Debate Continues in China

A few days ago I posted China Looks to 1998 on Reform; Overcapacity Has Been Faced 3 or 4 Times Already. The Economic Observer had a couple of articles on the late 1990s reform that saw major reductions in overcapacity, with massive layoffs at SOEs. This sparked a lot of discussion in China and the paper has an editorial on the subject out today. The final message: let the market clear. Eliminate local resistance to market forces.

Economic Observer newspaper published on January 11, "China Economic ponder 1998" article created quite a discussion. This resonance is largely due to an understanding that the current economic situation and in 1998 like, but those most concerned about China's economic prospects also believe that large changes in the current year compared to today's international and domestic macroeconomic environment, can not be in the same breath. In this context, China's economic restructuring in the new normal, and still depends on the continued deepening of reform and progress. Further clarify the relationship between the government and the market, let the market determine the survival of the fittest companies, is still the key issues of the reform options.

Ponder 1998, when production really should go "when off constantly, will be troubled," the determination, of course, this adjustment is painful, a large economy such restructuring is completed, go through the growing pains may not be short But if it continues to delay, the cost may be greater, the cost will be higher, but smaller room changed again. As the People's Daily reporter authoritative answer when asked earlier, in 1998 we also face sluggish external demand, insufficient domestic demand, overcapacity dilemma was to withstand pressure, the implementation of large-scale textile spindles limited production, only the later strong economy growth, only the overall national strength continued to improve today.

Determined to have been, how to productivity? Policymakers answer is clear. Supply-side structural reforms, the focus is still on reforms. Even in 1998, limiting the production of spindles to pull off than the more worthy of attention is still reform - which is always the main theme of China's economic development. State-owned enterprises, "encounter", "unintentional positive outcomes shade", a large number of small and medium state-owned enterprise restructuring, put out a number of private force, also put out a broad market space - what they created a new supply to meet the new demand. This makes possible the rapid rise of private enterprises, private enterprises grow bring a lot of new jobs, but also to create the conditions for the state-owned maneuvers, private virtually played the role of state-owned enterprise reform reducer. Statistics show that in urban employment in 1997, state-owned enterprises accounted for 53%, to 2002, private enterprises accounted for more than 70%. Moreover, at that time to promote other reforms, the impact is not limited to the moment. Such as housing reform finally let real estate has become one of China's economic power next decade, 1998 to start the tax reform can also be considered a large-scale tax cuts.

Promoting reform move the experience of China's economic reforms. This is also a wonderful look back to 1998 not to be missed. 1999 China's economic growth rate of 7.1%, hitting a low point. But it is this year, China completed the WTO negotiations with the United States, China's accession to the WTO a little clear obstacles, to do so in 2001 to become a WTO member. Thereafter, the opening Forced opening up, reform and opening up wheel drive, coupled with enormous resources, environment and demographic dividend, making China rapidly becoming the world's second largest economy, which the achievements of China's economic miracle in the first quarter.

We can say that today resolve excess capacity, disposal "zombie companies", policy makers uphold the concept of the past have been very different. 2013 Third Plenary Session of the CPC held eighteen have been identified, the market plays a decisive role in the allocation of resources. Thus, the structure is reasonable, to be judged by the market ultimately, survival of the fittest should market the final say, in line with this principle, "cut the Gordian knot" zombie disposal business, resolve excess capacity, China's economy was likely to be reborn, complete restructuring and economic engine conversion.

Of course, we think, how will the market fall on the operation principle, there should be a more effective response. Past control overcapacity, often encounter local barriers, some local officials at every turn with "excess others, I do not surplus" as an excuse for this excess real estate business more than a "care", whereby the stiff and dead zombie companies. Because of the presence of local protection, companies want to cross-regional, cross-industry mergers and acquisitions many obstacles, not to mention the full role of the entrepreneur. Determined to eliminate resistance in this area, it should be the key today to achieve market clearing.
EO: 温故1998:除了改革,还是改革

2016-01-15

What Happens If Chinese Herd Wants Dollars?

A small portion of Chinese investors were on the hunt for greenbacks last week (Chinese Herd Crashes Online Banking System in Hunt for Dollars), but that was only a portion of urban investors. What happens if the herd shows up and buying USD becomes hot enough that all the aunties want in as well?

WSJ: China’s Jittery Savers Could Pose Capital-Flight Threat
China’s urban population in 2014 came to 737 million, according to World Bank estimates.

Assume that the wealthiest 1%, who easily have enough savings, convert the maximum allowed amount into dollars this year. That would amount to nearly $370 billion of outflows. If the top 2% of urban individuals do so, it would mean $740 billion of outflows. That is to say nothing of the many other ways to get money out of the country, legal or otherwise.
Pretty soon we're talking real money.


It doesn't make sense to focus solely on the wealthy though. Several hundred million Chinese have enough savings to purchase at least $10,000 of USD as an investment/hedge. If 10% of the urban public converts an average of $15,000, it comes to over $1 trillion.

It also isn't exactly outflows if the dollars stay in country. The central bank can't spend those dollars without taking a double short position against depositors who now have USD bank accounts being paid interest in USD. The central bank could at some point force conversion back to yuan though, either temporarily or permanently.

Back in 2012 I wrote, much too early:
The takeaway is that the Chinese people have turned into U.S. dollar buyers, which will drain foreign currency from the central bank. Interest rates should be rising to defend the currency, but they are instead falling, opening up the potential for more significant devaluation later this year, most likely after the U.S. dollar strengthens and euro weakens.

There may be no major crisis in the currency, but that will depend on how much capital the central bank expends fighting devaluation. The country has moved from the dollar peg to a currency basket and advanced the internationalized the yuan, which will allow for more dollar outflows and depreciation should the greenback rally versus the yen and euro.

Finally, a yuan depreciation of 10% or more would be far from an FX crisis, but it would shock financial markets that remain overwhelmingly yuan bullish, especially because it will come in the midst of a global crisis. The psychological effects of a yuan devaluation expressed in the financial markets will far outweigh the economic impact.

China Real Estate Assn: Economy Still Relies on Real Estate

Miao Leru, China Real Estate Association Vice President & Secretary General, believes real estate is still the key to China's development.
First, the real estate industry is still a pillar industry within "Thirteenth Five-year plan" during a certain time of economic and social development, in 2014 in front of the data we are aware, this is the high point in 2013, according to that year's data, real estate investment 9.5 trillion, 6.4 trillion in residential investment, real estate sales of 763 million, residential sales of 624 million, the equivalent of 29.08% and 23.7% of the total retail sales of social consumer goods over the same period, respectively, to maintain such a scale, in China's economic and social development which is also a big, important, not to mention our real estate is not to maintain this scale, but along with the "Thirteen Five" start, urban development need to assume a greater role, facing more opportunities.

Second, the idea is to lead the five "Thirteen Five" development, real estate development for our proposed requirements of the times, people's livelihood, we solve poor tackling, the second is the face of ecological civilization and green development, upstream and downstream industries are required to change the development mode . As our products have green ecology standards, housing, buildings, structures need upgrading. We should reach the green, environmental protection, low-carbon, ecological civilization connected environment. From settlements, cities, new towns, the need to upgrade their level, to meet the demands of the times.
H

iFeng: 房地产业仍是我国经济社会发展的支柱产业

Market Exit Signal Triggered

Junk bond yield spreads triggered an exit signal on Wednesday. I am now oriented 100% for a bear market in my trading accounts.

From the start of 1997, this signal has returned the following on the Russell 3000 from 1997-01-01 to 2016-01-13 (all data from FRED, ignores all taxes and transaction fees):

Buy and Hold Russell 3000
$37,319.51.....273.2%
Long and Short on Exit Signal
$44,188.73.....341.9%
Long and Go to Cash on Signal
$41,468.57.....314.7%

The above is based on a "dumb" strategy of staying out of the market when the yield spread is above the exit signal. In reality, you would use other information to decide a re-entry point, but that it works well on a stupid setting is a good sign.

Following this signal would have you stay out of the market for nearly the entirety of the 2001 bear market, save a couple of re-entry head fakes. Same in 2008, first exit signal was February 2008. It would give you a headfakepalooza in 2011: exit and re-entry happening 3 times (6 trades) over the course of one month, and then 3 more head fakes over the next 3 months.

Even if if offered no excess return, using this signal reduces volatility: the worst trade was a 12% loss in 2002, a buy trade amid the bear market. The biggest loss on a short-trade was 7%.

The chart below shows the first exit signal and the final buy signal for each period.

There were 25 total trades, 10 came during the 2011 period between the first exit signal and final buy signal.
There were 8 trades during the 2008/2009 financial crisis.
There were 6 trades during the 2000-2003 bear market.
There is the exit signal from Wednesday and it went higher on Thursday.


Thanks to the guys at Alhambra Partners who noticed this signal. Stock Market Warning: Credit Spreads Are Widening Again

CNYXAU for 2016

Reuters: Giving up on stocks: China's retail investors seek safety first
"Except for gold, all other assets are just bubbles to me," said a 24-year-old female investor in Beijing. "I guess I am a pessimist. If there are really some global conflicts, even dollars and bonds could not buy a meal."

In just seven trading days at the start of this year, assets under management at HuaAn Gold ETF, China's biggest gold ETF, jumped 8 percent, after doubling during the previous six months.

"We notice a rise in gold investment whenever there's concern over yuan depreciation," said Richard Xu, the fund's manager. "Buying gold also helps investors avoid risks in equities. It serves double purposes."
Bonds and USD are also catching a bid...

Rising Money Supply and Falling Reserves

December Money Supply Growth

December M2 grew at 1.3% mom in December, the 5th fastest month of the year. Since December 2014 saws faster growth, yoy growth slowed to 13.3%.
Total social financing in December was the third highest monthly figure, almost tying June's figure. Reuters: China Dec new yuan loans hit 597.8 bln yuan, well short of expectations. Bloomberg: China's Credit Jumps Most Since June on Surging Bond Sales