2021-11-11

Demoralized Bears Remove the Dip Buying Safety Net

Signs of a top contniue piling up.

ZH: World's Most Bearish Hedge Fund Shuts Down: Here Is Russell Clark's Farewell Letter

The answer for me comes from China. China wants a strong currency, and to keep consumption strong. It seems to me that the Chinese government uses it extraordinary control of the economy to control activity and the currency through the commodity markets. To elaborate, I expected China to post a weak trade surplus in October, and for currency devaluation fears to spike (particularly after the recent Evergrande selloff). Chinese trade surplus was actually very strong. And it was strong because Chinese imports of oil and iron ore were down significantly. Chinese steel production was down a stunning 20% year on year, a number you would typically only see in a bad recession.

China has effectively taken control of key commodities, and now adjusts volumes to suit its own needs. Taking all this volatility through physical markets, has essentially collapsed financial market volatility, and also led to commodity currencies being significantly weaker than commodity prices – which has been a problem for me this year.

Now I understand this, non-obvious trades at the beginning of the year such as long oil, short iron ore now seem obvious. The surprising weakness of gold and other precious metals can make sense in this analysis. It also explains why the extraordinary fiscal and monetary policies of the US have not been met with greater commodity or bond turbulence. It is very hard for me to get bearish US treasuries when I see Chinese steel production down 20% year on year.

The big question then is whether this Chinese policy of absorbing financial risk in the physical economy sustainable? History suggests not, as most countries prefer to devalue than slow economic growth. However, I can see reasons why China may continue with this policy. The most powerful is that with US policymakers seemingly unable to raise interest rates, or balance budgets there is a gap in the market for a credible currency. Is China making a play for reserve currency status?

And this is why I am returning capital. Markets have now become a political choice. US markets are essentially a bet on the Fed unable to raise rates, and congress unable to regulate big tech or raise corporate tax rates. Commodity markets have now become a bet on Chinese policy objectives, and currencies have become a bet on what Chinese policy objectives are too.

Give me an economic problem, then I can properly gauge risk. Give me a Chinese political problem – I am taking a guess as much as the next person. Did I think Alibaba was going to fall 50% this year? No, not until the Chinese government told me to think that way. Is Alibaba a good short now? I have no idea, and like everyone else will have to wait to see what the Chinese government says.

So, I think it time to step back, have a think about where we are going, and then come back when I can see an opportunity for my skill set. Perhaps that’s never, but I doubt it. The only constant in life is change. This will be my final newsletter and it just leaves me to thank you for your support and wish you all the success in the future. From a personal perspective I plan to keep producing research, so keep an eye out for my future notes. Russell.

This is why I am always looking for big return trades that will payoff if and when the system blows up. Highly controlled, politically dominated markets will not peacefully revert to normal functioning. China will lose control of the yuan, the Federal Reserve will lose control of interest rates and so on.

Additionally, if markets are political then political analysis can drive investments. Much of the public and most of the ruling class is completely deluded by false narratives pumped out by mainstream media. Climate change and many of the investments around in are politically motivated. I'd wager the bulk of investors, via ESG, assuming Fed support and things like climate change, regulatory support for BigTech and BigPharma etc. are "all in" on the continued existence of the current ruling class in the United States. Yet that ruling class has been completely overthrown about once a century, in 1776, 1860, 1932 and ...?

More pertinent to the market, the bears are totally demoralized. I've seen anecdotal data supporting this. Bears admitting they are taking huge losses, thinking of or actually throwing in the towel, investment services losing subscribers because who needs advice when "just buy the dip"
and "YOLO your account on weekly call options" are winning strategies?

WSJ: Rich Millennials to Financial Advisers: Thanks for the Golf Invite, but You Can’t Invest My Money

“It’s easy to manage $500,000, $1 million yourself,” said Mr. Martocci, who says he spends less than an hour a week monitoring his investments.

More rich young investors are opting to go without a traditional financial adviser. Instead, they are betting they can get good-enough investment options from do-it-yourself digital platforms that are cheap and easy to use. Many also want to invest in riskier assets, like cryptocurrencies and tech startups, that mainstream advisers often don’t offer.

Some of this is generational, some of it is technology, but a big component is also the bull market making everyone feel competent.

No comments:

Post a Comment