The Federal Reserve was created for one purpose: to be the lender of last resort. To bail out the banking system during a systemic bank run. To protect the inflation, to save the debt that bankers created in the prior years, to prevent the crisis created by profligate bankers. It has since added many responsibilities and its role expanded, but its ultimate duty remains the system.
The Federal Reserve is the steward of the U.S. dollar. Inflation has become job number-one because there's no risk of bank failures as long as the currency system is stable. The currency system is only stable if inflation is low, if the public trusts in the value of the money.
While I remain in the "deflationist" camp in macroeconomics, I also believe trust in the currency is a higher-order phenomena. Most hyperinflations have occurred during or after wars, foreign invasion, or totalitarian takeovers. Zimbabwe implemented genocidal anti-white policies, Venezuela went full communist.Turkey's Erdogan has assumed dictatorial powers over the money supply and incipient hyperinflation is underway. Smaller inflations can be driven by lesser evils of government and social institutions. Trust in government matters, as does trust in the central bank.
The Federal Reserve doesn't control the bond market. It creates an illusion of control by going along with the bond market. For 40 years, including Volcker's term, they have appeared powerful because the bond market was in a bull market. As the central planners of the CCP look like geniuses for taking Mao's dead foot off the throats of the Chinese people, so do central bankers appear wizardly amid a 40-year boom. Volcker and Deng are lauded because they did the right thing at the right time, but the prosperity that followed was not their creation.
Fast forward to today. The Federal Reserve is under extreme institutional distress. Whether it realizes it or not, their credibility is in play. Their illusion of power is at risk. If the public stops trusting in the Fed's inflation-fighting credentials, they will begin dumping the U.S. currency for assets such as oil, gold and wheat. The Federal Reserve will have two choices when that happens: hike rates (eventually) so high that it triggers a 1930s-level depression or let the currency system collapse. They tried threading the needle in the 1970s and ended up with the worst recession of the past 100 years outside of the Great Depression (and ignoring the government-created lockdowns of 2020). They cannot thread the needle this time because conditions are worse. Private credit was low in the 1970s. Demographics were highly favorable. The government's debt-to-GDP was low enough that high rates didn't bankrupt it. The opposite is true today.
As of today, producer price inflation is near 10 percent. It doesn't matter if it is coming down next year. The Fed's credibility is at risk today. Their action today will tell the public if they place asset prices ahead of inflation. If they are willing to make a hard choice to stop inflation. If I was in charge, I would tell the FOMC we have a free shot today. Inflation is very likely coming down next year. If we do some mumbo jumbo today, we'll look like geniuses. So what should we do? I'd vote to end the taper today. No more asset purchases. In light of high inflastion and high employment gains (last month was not a miss), with stocks near all-time highs and commodities such as oil still threatening to drive inflation higher, why is the Federal Reserve still doing quantitative easing? It makes no sense, unless they are afraid to do anything that might upset crack-addled speculators who cannot stomach a 5 percent drawdwn, let alone 10 percent. Like the an inversion of the 1980s mini-depression that killed the inflation, this time the Federal Reserve must risk a mini-crash in asset markets to restore their credibility as inflation fighters. Where they started a bull market in 1982, the might have created a bear market by pumping the market to new highs the past 20 months.
What does the market believe? Most markets are calm today as everyone waits for the policy statement. Palladium is sending a bearish signal for tech...which might hint sentimentt is a little more bearish than seems at first glance...
No comments:
Post a Comment