2021-10-06

Central Planning Always Fails

China would be as rich as Japan, South Korea, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Singapore if the CCP never existed. China has made great progress, but if you take your boot off a man's neck, he will also appear to grow rapidly as he stands at his normal height.

China's leaders are more intelligent than in the West, but they are still planners. Look closely at their policies and you will see they achieved the most when they stepped back and let the people rise to their natural level. This isn't an argument for letting the market run amok, but for example in housing, there are endless regulations. Only the most draconian seem to have any effect because credit drives the bubble.

The CCP looks smart and successful because they took their boot of the necks of the Chinese people. They stand in front and say, "Look what we have achieved!"

The Federal Reserve is far less powerful than the CCP. They have no real power these days. If you look closely at the Federal Reserve's policies, they follow the market when setting interest rates. Their main power is in creating the illusion of control, the illusion of stability and the illusion of printing money. If the market loses faith in the Federal Reserve, or believes they aren't powerful enough to meet the challenge, the Federal Reserve doesn't have the power to stop that. Even if they expanded their power to buy stocks like th BOJ (as some speculate will happen), they cannot control how investors interpret that, cannot control how that reaction plays out in currency markets. They do not control the value of the U.S. dollar or market interest rates.

The Federal Reserve looks successful when it is rising positive waves of social mood that accompany economic expansions. It's the same for presidents and political parties. The post-2008 era in the West and China can be described as a slow authoritarian creep as these institutions try to take control over the economy and political system because they fear what will happen when they inevitably lose control, or lose that illuision. The political consolidation by Xi and the Cathedral in the USA (where USG has now stooped to unleashing the DOJ on people who complain at school board meetings) is in preparation. It is conscious in China I believe, becauset their leadership is more intelligent, more competent, more just in the sense of ruling over their people for the general benefit of their people. In the West, it seems unconscious. The leadership is thoroughly corrupt. China has surface corruption, mostly cash for deals. The West's ruling class is morally corrupt. The are not just, they rule over "their" people as if the people are a hated, conquered enemy. The lie about everything. Even basic science such as the male and female sex are lied about. Most of them probably do not understand, not even at a small level, how close the whole house of cards could come down. They sense somewhat how they are hated and opposed, which is why they are governing like a cornered animal.

Timing is impossible, but what I expect will happen at some point (with now being another window of possibility) is all of these illusions will be shattered by a financial, economic, poltiical, social and cultural crisis that they lose control over. They will lose control because they never had control to begin with. They are riding a wave of demographics, expanding credit, societal optimism, technological progress and the good policy of their ancestors (here the CCP has a legitimate claim to say they made the choice to abandon Maoism). When these waves come crashing into the shore, it will be obvious that they have no power over the tides. In China this will have economic repercussions more than anything else. If the West remains free, it will mean a societal revolution that overthrows the current ruling class or at least reforms at a scale similar to FDR's remaking of USG in the 1930s.

No comments:

Post a Comment